Erfani Goran, McCready Jemma, Nichol Bethany, Gordon Charlotte, Unsworth John, Croston Michelle, Comparcini Dania, Simonetti Valentina, Cicolini Giancarlo, Mikkonen Kristina, Keisala Jeremia, Tomietto Marco
Department of Nursing, Midwifery and Health, Faculty of Health and Life Sciences, Northumbria University, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK.
Department of Social Work, Education and Community Wellbeing, Faculty of Health and Life Sciences, Northumbria University, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK.
Int Nurs Rev. 2025 Jun;72(2):e13035. doi: 10.1111/inr.13035. Epub 2024 Aug 19.
To profile the characteristics of nurses with varying levels of vaccine hesitancy toward the COVID-19 and influenza vaccines.
In many countries across the world, healthcare workers, and nurses in particular, display significant reluctance toward COVID-19 and influenza vaccines due to concerns about safety, distrust in healthcare policies, and media influences. To address this, a proposed approach involves profiling nurses to tailor vaccination campaigns and to improve acceptance rates and public health outcomes.
This cross-sectional study adopted the Vaccination Attitudes Examination scale to assess hesitancy toward COVID-19 and influenza vaccines among 294 registered nurses in the UK between March and July 2023. A K-means cluster analysis was performed. The Strengthening the Reporting of Observational Studies in Epidemiology guidelines were adopted.
Three profiles were identified. Profile A showed low vaccination hesitancy, profile B showed average hesitancy, and profile C showed high hesitancy toward vaccines. The highest concern for all profiles was related to unforeseen future effects of vaccination. Profile C had more nurses in early career roles, whereas nurses in profiles A and B were in more senior roles. Profile A showed higher educational attainment. Nurses in profile C used Snapchat more, whereas nurses in profile A used Twitter more frequently.
This study identified specific characteristics associated with higher levels of vaccination hesitancy in nursing. Unforeseen future effects of vaccination are a core aspect to consider in promoting vaccination.
Policies and vaccination campaigns should be targeted on early career nurses and should deliver tailored messages to dispel misinformation about unforeseen future effects of vaccination through specific social media platforms. Senior nurses should be involved as role models in promoting vaccination. These results are key for enhancing an evidence-based approach to implementing global health policies in healthcare.
剖析对新冠疫苗和流感疫苗存在不同程度犹豫态度的护士的特征。
在世界上许多国家,医护人员,尤其是护士,由于对安全性的担忧、对医疗政策的不信任以及媒体影响,对新冠疫苗和流感疫苗表现出明显的抵触情绪。为解决这一问题,一种建议的方法是剖析护士群体,以定制疫苗接种宣传活动,提高接种率并改善公共卫生结果。
这项横断面研究采用疫苗接种态度检查量表,于2023年3月至7月期间评估了英国294名注册护士对新冠疫苗和流感疫苗的犹豫程度。进行了K均值聚类分析。采用了加强流行病学观察性研究报告的指南。
识别出三种类型。A类显示出低疫苗接种犹豫程度,B类显示出中等犹豫程度,C类对疫苗表现出高犹豫程度。所有类型最担忧的都是疫苗接种的不可预见的未来影响。C类中有更多处于早期职业阶段的护士,而A类和B类中的护士处于更高级别的职位。A类显示出更高的教育程度。C类护士更多使用Snapchat,而A类护士更频繁使用Twitter。
本研究确定了护理工作中与较高疫苗接种犹豫程度相关的特定特征。疫苗接种的不可预见的未来影响是促进疫苗接种时要考虑的一个核心方面。
政策和疫苗接种宣传活动应针对早期职业护士,并应通过特定社交媒体平台传递量身定制的信息,以消除有关疫苗接种不可预见的未来影响的错误信息。高级护士应作为榜样参与促进疫苗接种。这些结果对于加强在医疗保健中实施全球卫生政策的循证方法至关重要。