33d Fighter Wing Aviator Performance Team, Eglin Air Force Base, FL 32542, USA.
56th Fighter Wing Human Performance Team, Luke Air Force Base, AZ 85309, USA.
Mil Med. 2024 Aug 19;189(Suppl 3):465-470. doi: 10.1093/milmed/usae153.
Military fighter aircrew report high rates of cervical pain and injury. There is currently no consensus regarding the best training methods for this population. Eglin Air Force Base (AFB) and Luke AFB have multidisciplinary teams specializing in aircrew training, performance, and injury mitigation. All student pilots (SPs) completing Basic Course training at these locations engage in an 8-week Spine Training Program (STP). The STP originated at Luke AFB in 2020 and was expanded to Eglin AFB in 2022. The primary aim of this study was to assess whether the STP led to significant changes in the performance measure studied, Cervical Endurance Hold (CEH). Further, this study aimed to determine if the CEH training effect was independent of location of STP administration. We hypothesized that SPs would exhibit statistically significant CEH training adaptations irrespective of base location.
Air Force F-16 and F-35 SPs from Luke AFB and Eglin AFB were actively enrolled in the Basic Course and participated in the standardized STP from 2020 to 2023. The CEH test was administered prior to (intake) and following (exit) the 8-week STP. SPSS for Windows version 29 software (IBM, Armonk, NY) was used to retrospectively analyze the data from this study. Participants were excluded if they were unable to perform the CEH test at intake or exit. The study was approved by the Air Force Research Laboratory Institutional Review Board and was performed in accordance with the ethical standards of the Declaration of Helsinki.
One hundred and ninety-eight SPs (Luke AFB, males n = 170, females n = 12; Eglin AFB, males n = 16) completed the STP program. There was no significant difference between intake and exit concerning age, height, weight, % body fat, and fat-free mass at Luke AFB or Eglin AFB (P < 0.05). Statistically significant improvements in CEH were observed within all groups from intake to exit (P < 0.001). When considering all participants collectively, there was a notable 33.6% increase in CEH from intake to exit (P < 0.001) with an overall effect size of d = 1.14. When analyzing specific subgroups, females from Luke AFB experienced a significant 20.4% increase in CEH (P < 0.001, d = 1.14), males from Luke AFB exhibited a significant 34.5% increase (P < 0.001, d = 1.09), and males from Eglin AFB demonstrated a significant increase of 55.7% in CEH (P < 0.001, d = 1.97).
This retrospective analysis showed significant improvements in the CEH across all groups following the completion of the STP. Furthermore, CEH results from both bases exhibited a large effect size indicating a meaningful change was found between intake and exit regardless of training location. These preliminary study results should be interpreted with caution as a control group was unable to be established. In the future, a randomized control trial should be performed to test the STP used in this study against other STP programs. This may better inform experts on the best spine training methods for fighter aircrew.
军事战斗机机组人员报告颈椎疼痛和损伤的发生率很高。目前,对于该人群的最佳训练方法还没有共识。埃格林空军基地(AFB)和卢克空军基地(Luke AFB)都有专门从事机组人员培训、表现和伤害减轻的多学科团队。在这些地点完成基础课程培训的所有学生飞行员(SP)都参加为期 8 周的脊柱训练计划(STP)。STP 最初于 2020 年在卢克空军基地推出,并于 2022 年扩展到埃格林空军基地。本研究的主要目的是评估 STP 是否导致研究的绩效测量指标——颈椎耐力保持(CEH)的显著变化。此外,本研究旨在确定 CEH 训练效果是否独立于 STP 管理地点。我们假设,无论基地位置如何,SP 都会表现出统计学上显著的 CEH 训练适应性。
来自卢克空军基地和埃格林空军基地的空军 F-16 和 F-35 SP 积极参加基础课程,并参加了 2020 年至 2023 年的标准化 STP。在 8 周的 STP 前后(摄入和退出)进行 CEH 测试。使用 Windows 版本 29 软件(IBM,Armonk,NY)的 SPSS for Windows 对来自这项研究的数据进行回顾性分析。如果参与者在摄入或退出时无法进行 CEH 测试,则将其排除在外。这项研究得到了空军研究实验室机构审查委员会的批准,并按照赫尔辛基宣言的伦理标准进行。
198 名 SP(卢克空军基地,男性 n = 170,女性 n = 12;埃格林空军基地,男性 n = 16)完成了 STP 计划。卢克空军基地或埃格林空军基地的摄入和退出时,年龄、身高、体重、体脂百分比和去脂体重没有显著差异(P < 0.05)。所有组从摄入到退出时,CEH 均有显著改善(P < 0.001)。当考虑所有参与者时,CEH 从摄入到退出时增加了 33.6%(P < 0.001),整体效应量为 d = 1.14。在分析特定亚组时,卢克空军基地的女性 CEH 显著增加了 20.4%(P < 0.001,d = 1.14),卢克空军基地的男性 CEH 显著增加了 34.5%(P < 0.001,d = 1.09),而埃格林空军基地的男性 CEH 则显著增加了 55.7%(P < 0.001,d = 1.97)。
这项回顾性分析表明,所有组在完成 STP 后,CEH 均有显著改善。此外,两个基地的 CEH 结果都表现出较大的效应量,表明无论训练地点如何,在摄入和退出之间都发现了有意义的变化。由于无法建立对照组,因此应谨慎解释这些初步研究结果。未来,应进行随机对照试验,以测试这项研究中使用的 STP 与其他 STP 方案相比。这可能会为专家提供有关战斗机机组人员最佳脊柱训练方法的更好信息。