Brody School of Medicine, East Carolina University, Greenville, NC, USA.
University of California San Francisco, San Francisco, CA, USA.
Arch Dermatol Res. 2024 Aug 20;316(8):543. doi: 10.1007/s00403-024-03305-5.
Actinic keratosis (AK) is a common precancerous skin condition predominantly affecting older males with fair skin and significant UV exposure. The clinical significance of AK is related to its potential for malignant transformation and progression to squamous cell carcinoma (SCC). Accurate diagnosis of AK is essential for adequate treatment, evaluation of therapeutic efficacy, and mitigating the risk of developing SCC. However, clinician variability due to the subjective nature of current diagnostic tools presents significant challenges to achieving consistent and reliable AK diagnoses. Thus, there is no universally accepted standard for measuring AK.This review evaluates current methods for evaluating and diagnosing AK, focusing on clinician variability through inter- and intraobserver agreement. Eight peer-reviewed studies investigating the reliability of various approaches for AK evaluation show substantial variability in interobserver or intraobserver agreement, with most methods demonstrating only slight to moderate reliability. Some suggest that consensus discussions and simplified rating scales can modestly improve diagnostic reliability. However, remaining variability and the lack of a universally accepted standard for measuring AK underscore the need for more robust and standardized diagnostic and evaluation methods.The review emphasizes the need for improved diagnostic tools and standardized methods to enhance the accuracy and reliability of AK assessments. It also proposes applying a novel examination approach using 1,3-dihydroxyacetone (DHA) staining which may improve the visualization and identification of AK lesions. Advancements in these areas have significant potential, promising better clinical practices and patient outcomes in AK management.
光化性角化病(AK)是一种常见的癌前皮肤疾病,主要影响皮肤白皙且有大量紫外线暴露史的老年男性。AK 的临床意义与其恶性转化和进展为鳞状细胞癌(SCC)的潜力有关。AK 的准确诊断对于充分治疗、评估治疗效果以及降低 SCC 发生风险至关重要。然而,由于当前诊断工具的主观性,临床医生之间存在很大的差异,这对实现一致和可靠的 AK 诊断提出了重大挑战。因此,目前还没有普遍接受的 AK 测量标准。
本综述评估了目前用于评估和诊断 AK 的方法,重点关注通过观察者间和观察者内一致性来评估临床医生的差异。八项同行评议的研究调查了各种 AK 评估方法的可靠性,结果显示观察者间或观察者内的一致性存在很大差异,大多数方法仅显示出轻微到中度的可靠性。一些研究表明,共识讨论和简化的评分量表可以适度提高诊断的可靠性。然而,剩余的差异以及缺乏普遍接受的 AK 测量标准,突显了需要更强大和标准化的诊断和评估方法。
本综述强调了需要改进诊断工具和标准化方法,以提高 AK 评估的准确性和可靠性。还提出了一种使用 1,3-二羟基丙酮(DHA)染色的新型检查方法,该方法可能改善 AK 病变的可视化和识别。这些领域的进展具有很大的潜力,有望在 AK 管理方面改善临床实践和患者结局。