Symbiosis School of Sports Sciences, Symbiosis International (Deemed University), Pune, India.
Department of Physical Education and Sports Education, Faculty of Sports Sciences, Burdur Mehmet Akif Ersoy University, Burdur, Turkey.
J Sports Sci. 2024 Jul;42(14):1367-1389. doi: 10.1080/02640414.2024.2391657. Epub 2024 Aug 20.
Combining traditional resistance and ballistic exercises in a complex training (CT) format has shown improved physical fitness compared to the control conditions. However, no meta-analysis has directly compared CT with traditional resistance training (RT) alone. A systematic search was conducted in PubMed, Scopus, and WoS. Thirty-two studies involving 726 participants were included. Both RT and CT similarly improved one-repetition maximum (1RM) squat and bench press, 10 m and 30-60 m linear sprint time, squat jump height, jump power, reactive strength index, and standing long jump distance. Compared to RT, CT favoured 5-m (ES = 0.96) and 20-m linear sprint (ES = 0.52), change-of-direction speed (CODS; ES = 0.39), and countermovement jump height (CMJ; ES = 0.36). Furthermore, moderating effects of training frequency, duration, and complex training type were reported. Certainty of evidence was considered low for 5-m and 20-m linear sprints and CODS and very low for other outcomes. Compared to traditional resistance training, complex training may improve 5-m and 20-m linear sprints, CODS, and CMJ height. The effects of complex training may be optimised by longer interventions (≥7 weeks), with ~ 3 weekly training sessions, and using ascending and contrast training formats. However, the certainty of evidence ranges from very low to low.
将传统的抗阻训练和弹道训练结合到复杂训练(CT)中,与对照条件相比,已显示出对身体素质的改善。然而,目前还没有直接将 CT 与传统的抗阻训练(RT)进行比较的荟萃分析。我们在 PubMed、Scopus 和 WoS 中进行了系统检索。共纳入 32 项研究,涉及 726 名参与者。RT 和 CT 均同样提高了 1 次重复最大重量(1RM)深蹲和卧推、10m 和 30-60m 直线冲刺时间、深蹲跳高度、跳力量、反应力量指数和立定跳远距离。与 RT 相比,CT 更有利于 5m(ES=0.96)和 20m 直线冲刺(ES=0.52)、变向速度(CODS;ES=0.39)和深蹲跳高度(CMJ;ES=0.36)。此外,还报告了训练频率、持续时间和复杂训练类型的调节作用。5m 和 20m 直线冲刺以及 CODS 的证据确定性被认为较低,而其他结果的证据确定性非常低。与传统的抗阻训练相比,复杂训练可能会提高 5m 和 20m 直线冲刺、CODS 和 CMJ 高度。通过更长的干预(≥7 周)、每周约 3 次训练以及使用递增和对比训练格式,复杂训练的效果可能会得到优化。然而,证据的确定性从非常低到低不等。