Hess Julia Meredith, Magan Ifrah Mahamud, Goodkind Jessica R
Department of Pediatrics, University of New Mexico, Albuquerque, New Mexico, USA.
Silver School of Social Work, New York University, New York, New York, USA.
Am J Community Psychol. 2025 Mar;75(1-2):53-67. doi: 10.1002/ajcp.12763. Epub 2024 Aug 20.
Growing evidence supports the importance of culturally appropriate mental health interventions, yet it is not always feasible to develop culturally grounded interventions or adapt existing interventions for each cultural group. In addition, these approaches do not recognize the multiple intersecting aspects of culture and identity that individuals, families, and communities possess. Thus, an essential question is whether culturally appropriate mental health interventions have to be culturally specific. We address this question by examining processes of the Refugee Well-being Project (RWP), a community-based mental health intervention for refugees resettled in the United States, which included people from multiple cultural groups (Afghanistan, Great Lakes region of Africa, Iraq, and Syria) and was grounded in common experiences of forcibly displaced people from marginalized backgrounds. RWP incorporates a practice-based concept of culture, an intersectional view of identity, and a multilevel approach to address postmigration stressors. Semistructured qualitative interviews were conducted with 290 participants at preintervention, followed by interviews at three timepoints with a purposively selected subsample (n = 66). Additional interviews (n = 101) were conducted with refugee and student partners. Four themes demonstrated key principles for creating culturally appropriate interventions with diverse groups: (a) recognize cultural complexity in practice; (b) focus on how racism and discrimination are experienced in everyday life; (c) de-center dominant US culture; and (d) create an egalitarian, inclusive space to put principles into action. We conclude that mental health interventions implemented with multiple, diverse groups can be culturally appropriate and effective without being culturally specific.
越来越多的证据支持了具有文化适应性的心理健康干预措施的重要性,但针对每个文化群体开发基于文化的干预措施或调整现有干预措施并不总是可行的。此外,这些方法没有认识到个人、家庭和社区所具有的文化和身份的多重交叉方面。因此,一个关键问题是,具有文化适应性的心理健康干预措施是否必须具有文化特异性。我们通过研究难民福祉项目(RWP)的过程来解决这个问题,该项目是一项针对在美国重新安置的难民的社区心理健康干预措施,其中包括来自多个文化群体(阿富汗、非洲大湖地区、伊拉克和叙利亚)的人,并且基于来自边缘化背景的被迫流离失所者的共同经历。RWP纳入了基于实践的文化概念、身份的交叉性观点以及应对移民后应激源的多层次方法。在干预前对290名参与者进行了半结构化定性访谈,随后对一个有目的选择的子样本(n = 66)在三个时间点进行了访谈。还对难民和学生合作伙伴进行了额外的访谈(n = 101)。四个主题展示了与不同群体创建具有文化适应性的干预措施的关键原则:(a)在实践中认识文化复杂性;(b)关注日常生活中如何体验种族主义和歧视;(c)使美国主流文化去中心化;(d)创建一个平等、包容的空间以将原则付诸行动。我们得出结论,针对多个不同群体实施的心理健康干预措施可以在不具有文化特异性的情况下具有文化适应性且有效。