Munakampe Margarate Nzala, Ngoma-Hazemba Alice, Sampa Mutale, Jacobs Choolwe N
Department of Health Policy and Management, School of Public Health, University of Zambia, Lusaka, Zambia.
Yakini Health Research Institute, Lusaka, Zambia.
Front Reprod Health. 2024 Aug 6;6:1399289. doi: 10.3389/frph.2024.1399289. eCollection 2024.
Despite substantial investment in improving healthcare among adolescents in low- and middle-income countries, barriers to access and utilization of services persist, especially to sexual and reproductive health (SRH) services. In response to adolescents' health service needs due to their vulnerability, interventions aimed at improving access and utilization of sexual and reproductive health services have been implemented in specific regions of Zambia. To highlight progress in the access and the overall delivery of services in Zambia, in the wake of a system-level funding mechanism, this paper aims to understand the accessibility, availability, acceptability and quality (AAAQ) of health services provided to young people.
In a qualitative case study, 48 discussions- 32 individual interviews with stakeholders and 16 focus group discussions, consisting of 128 male and female adolescents were conducted in six districts from Eastern, Southern and Muchinga provinces of Zambia. Interviews were audio-recorded, recordings transcribed verbatim, and transcripts were analysed using deductive thematic analysis, using the AAAQ framework and Atun's framework on integration, as a guide to reporting the findings.
We found that adolescents knew of and had access to common commodities and services- male condoms, health education and HIV counselling and testing. However, availability was affected by access-related barriers such as frequent stock-outs and insufficiently trained healthcare providers. In addition, accessibility was more restricted during the COVID-19 pandemic lockdown and compounded by the low acceptability of SRH service among adolescents across all contexts. This led to the use of alternatives such as herbal medicine and maintained common myths and misconceptions. The overall quality was marred by the lack of dedicated spaces for adolescent health services and the lack of information, education and communication (IEC) materials in some spaces.
While it was noted that some services were available for adolescents in all the study sites, numerous barriers inhibited access to these services and had an impact on the quality-of-service provision. With the added restriction to SRH service asses for young people, due to the low acceptability of adolescent SRH service use, the overall integration of adolescent SRH interventions into routine service provision was low and can be improved by targeting contextual barriers and maintaining best practices.
尽管在改善低收入和中等收入国家青少年的医疗保健方面投入了大量资金,但获得和利用服务的障碍依然存在,尤其是性与生殖健康(SRH)服务方面。鉴于青少年因易受伤害而产生的健康服务需求,赞比亚的特定地区已实施了旨在改善性与生殖健康服务的获取和利用的干预措施。为了突出赞比亚在服务获取和整体提供方面的进展,在建立了系统层面的资金机制之后,本文旨在了解向年轻人提供的健康服务的可及性、可得性、可接受性和质量(AAAQ)。
在一项定性案例研究中,在赞比亚东部、南部和穆钦加省的六个地区进行了48次讨论——与利益相关者进行了32次个人访谈以及16次焦点小组讨论,参与讨论的有128名青少年男女。访谈进行了录音,录音逐字转录,使用演绎主题分析法对转录本进行分析,以AAAQ框架和阿通的整合框架为指导来报告研究结果。
我们发现青少年知晓并能够获得常见的商品和服务——男用避孕套、健康教育以及艾滋病毒咨询和检测。然而,可得性受到与获取相关的障碍影响,如频繁缺货和医疗保健提供者培训不足。此外,在新冠疫情封锁期间,可及性受到更多限制,并且在所有情况下青少年对性与生殖健康服务的低接受度使情况更加复杂。这导致了诸如使用草药等替代方式,并维持了常见的误解和错误观念。整体质量因缺乏青少年健康服务的专用空间以及一些场所缺乏信息、教育和宣传(IEC)材料而受到损害。
虽然注意到在所有研究地点都有一些服务可供青少年使用,但众多障碍阻碍了他们获得这些服务,并对服务提供质量产生了影响。由于青少年对性与生殖健康服务使用的低接受度,对年轻人获得性与生殖健康服务又增加了限制,性与生殖健康干预措施在常规服务提供中的整体整合程度较低,通过针对具体情况的障碍并维持最佳实践可以加以改善。