Yadav Priyanka, Bishariya Nitin, Lather Jasbir, Dhattarwal S K, Sharma Neelkamal, Lohhra Arun
Department of Forensic Science, Maharshi Dayanand University, Rohtak, Haryana, 124001, India.
Department of Forensic Medicine, PGIMS, Rohtak, Haryana, 124001, India.
Forensic Sci Med Pathol. 2025 Mar;21(1):42-55. doi: 10.1007/s12024-024-00861-0. Epub 2024 Aug 22.
Dissolving bodies is a contemporary method of disposing of human remains and has been practiced throughout the years. This research article discussed the impact of readily available corrosive chemicals, such as Hydrochloric acid (HCl), Sulfuric acid (HSO), and Expelz™ toilet cleaner, on human bone. Unfortunately, the existing literature on this subject is scarce, with only a few studies conducted on human bones. To address this gap, we conducted an experimental analysis using human sternum bone fragments. These samples were subjected to immersion in different acids, namely HCl and HSO, at two concentrations (10% and 37%), and Expelz™ toilet cleaner. This research aims to describe the impact of toilet cleaner, sulphuric acid, and hydrochloric acid on bone tissue deterioration at various time intervals. Further, the morphological alterations weight loss, and cytological analysis of bone tissue residue with various acid concentrations and immersion times (3.5, 9, 24, 36, 48, 60, and 72 h) were analyzed. Among the chemicals examined, it is evident that 37% hydrochloric acid (HCl) and sulfuric acid (HSO), regardless of refreshment, exhibit the highest reactivity, resulting in the complete decomposition of hard tissue within a few hours. In contrast, the behaviour of 10% HSO reveals a more intricate degradation process characterized by fluctuations in weight loss. These distinct reactivity profiles under different conditions are crucial in understanding the potential for rapid weight loss, signifying high reactivity and more gradual weight loss, indicating a faster decomposition rate. Notably, refreshment of the solution enhanced the reactivity of both HCl and HSO.
溶解尸体是一种当代处理人类遗体的方法,多年来一直在实践。这篇研究文章讨论了容易获得的腐蚀性化学物质,如盐酸(HCl)、硫酸(H₂SO₄)和Expelz™马桶清洁剂,对人体骨骼的影响。不幸的是,关于这个主题的现有文献很少,只有少数关于人体骨骼的研究。为了填补这一空白,我们使用人类胸骨骨碎片进行了实验分析。这些样本被浸泡在不同的酸中,即HCl和H₂SO₄,浓度分别为10%和37%,以及Expelz™马桶清洁剂。本研究旨在描述马桶清洁剂、硫酸和盐酸在不同时间间隔对骨组织退化的影响。此外,还分析了不同酸浓度和浸泡时间(3.5、9、24、36、48、60和72小时)下骨组织残渣的形态改变、重量损失和细胞学分析。在所研究的化学物质中,很明显37%的盐酸(HCl)和硫酸(H₂SO₄),无论是否更换溶液,都表现出最高的反应性,导致硬组织在几小时内完全分解。相比之下,10%的H₂SO₄的行为显示出一个更复杂的降解过程,其特征是重量损失波动。这些在不同条件下不同的反应性特征对于理解快速失重的可能性至关重要,快速失重表明反应性高,而更缓慢的失重表明分解速度更快。值得注意的是,更换溶液增强了HCl和H₂SO₄的反应性。