Sekiguchi Kenji, Kawano Seiji, Chihara Norio, Satomi-Kobayashi Seimi, Maeda Eiichi, Matsumoto Riki
Division of Neurology, Kobe University Graduate School of Medicine, Kobe, Japan.
Integrated Clinical Education Center, Kobe University Hospital, Kobe, Japan.
JMIR Form Res. 2024 Aug 22;8:e50128. doi: 10.2196/50128.
Although neurology department ward rounds are among the most important medical education exercises in Japan, they have several issues. Patients may find it unpleasant to undergo repeated neurological tests, especially when in the presence of several students. Only the front row of students can closely observe the examination findings; moreover, students were prohibited from contacting patients altogether during the COVID-19 pandemic. One possible solution is to use commercial videoconferencing systems. However, Japanese patients are reluctant to have their medical information or video footage of them sent outside of the hospital via the internet.
The study aimed to confirm the feasibility of conducting remote teaching rounds using an in-house web conferencing system in which the patients' personal data are securely protected. This study also explored whether using remote rounds alongside face-to-face participation would enhance learning.
We created an on-premises videoconferencing system using an open-source app. To perform video ward rounds, the professor wore a wireless microphone while leading routine in-person rounds and the attending physician carried a tablet device linked to a web conference, allowing students in another room to watch the rounds on a live stream. In total, 112 of 5th-year students who entered their 1-week neurology rotation between 2021 and 2022 were instructed to participate in 1-hour in-person and remote rounds. Students were given questionnaires to evaluate their satisfaction and the educational effects of the remote rounds.
The remote ward rounds were conducted easily with no interference with the in-person rounds, nor any complaints from the patients. Each examination technique was explained by another teacher to the students who participated in remote rounds in the conference room. Characteristic neurological findings, such as plantar reflexes (Babinski sign), which are usually seen only by close observers during in-person rounds, could be visualized under magnification by all students. The postexperience survey (82/112, 73% response rate) showed that the mean score of participants' satisfaction was 3.94 (SD 0.83; excellent 5 and poor 1). No participant scoring 1 was noted. The proportion of students who observed 6 representative abnormal neurological findings (Babinski sign, hyperreflexia, cerebellar ataxia, involuntary movement, muscular weakness, and abnormality in sensory examination) increased by 22% (18/82, range 13-24) compared to in-person rounds alone. When self-rating the learning value, 43% (35/82) of the students answered that remote rounds are equally as valuable as in-person rounds, while 32% (26/82) preferred remote rounds.
Live-streaming of neurology ward rounds using a secure in-house web conferencing system provides additional learning experience without concerns regarding leakage of patient information. This initiative could enhance neurology learning before entering a clinical clerkship.
尽管神经内科病房查房是日本最重要的医学教育活动之一,但仍存在一些问题。患者可能会觉得反复接受神经学检查很不愉快,尤其是在有多名学生在场的时候。只有前排的学生才能近距离观察检查结果;此外,在新冠疫情期间,学生被完全禁止接触患者。一种可能的解决方案是使用商业视频会议系统。然而,日本患者不愿意通过互联网将他们的医疗信息或视频资料发送到医院之外。
本研究旨在确认使用内部网络会议系统进行远程教学查房的可行性,该系统能安全保护患者的个人数据。本研究还探讨了在面对面参与的同时使用远程查房是否会提高学习效果。
我们使用一个开源应用程序创建了一个内部视频会议系统。为了进行视频查房,教授在进行常规面对面查房时佩戴无线麦克风,主治医师携带与网络会议相连的平板电脑设备,让另一个房间的学生能够观看查房直播。在2021年至2022年期间进入为期1周神经内科轮转的112名五年级学生中,全部被要求参加1小时的面对面查房和远程查房。学生们收到问卷,以评估他们的满意度和远程查房的教育效果。
远程病房查房轻松进行,没有干扰面对面查房,也没有患者投诉。每种检查技术都由另一位教师向在会议室参加远程查房的学生进行解释。典型的神经学检查结果,如巴宾斯基征等跖反射,在面对面查房时通常只有近距离观察者才能看到,而现在所有学生都能在放大的情况下看到。经验后调查(82/112,回复率73%)显示,参与者满意度的平均得分为3.94(标准差0.83;优秀为5分,差为1分)。没有参与者给出1分。观察到6种代表性异常神经学检查结果(巴宾斯基征、反射亢进、小脑共济失调、不自主运动、肌肉无力和感觉检查异常)的学生比例比仅进行面对面查房时增加了22%(18/82,范围13 - 24)。在对学习价值进行自我评估时,43%(35/82)的学生回答远程查房与面对面查房同样有价值,而32%(26/82)的学生更喜欢远程查房。
使用安全的内部网络会议系统对神经内科病房查房进行直播,可提供额外的学习体验,且无需担心患者信息泄露。这一举措可以在进入临床实习前加强神经学学习。