Department of Orthodontics, Faculty of Dentistry, Hacettepe University, Ankara, Turkey.
J Dent Educ. 2020 Mar;84(3):377-384. doi: 10.21815/JDE.019.172.
The aims of this study were to evaluate the effects of a live-video teaching tool on the performance of dental students in bending an orthodontic vestibular arch and to assess the students' perceptions of the technology. All 135 fourth-year dental students in the 2018 academic year at Hacettepe Dental School, Ankara, Turkey, were invited to participate in the study; after exclusions, the remaining 116 were randomly divided into two demonstration cohorts. These students had no prior experience bending an orthodontic wire. Cohort 1 (control, N=58) was shown a conventional live demonstration of the orthodontic bending of a vestibular arch, and Cohort 2 (experimental, N=58) was shown a live-video demonstration of the same procedure. Both cohorts saw the demonstration before beginning the exercise and were evaluated afterwards on their performance of the procedure. In addition, the students' perceptions of the demonstration techniques were collected with a questionnaire. The results did not show any significant differences in the students' bending scores between the control and experimental cohorts (p=0.767). The median values on the questionnaire indicated almost no statistically significant difference in responses between the cohorts. The only significant difference was that Cohort 1 had a higher percentage who answered "yes" they would like to rewatch the demonstration than did Cohort 2 (p=0.024). In this study, the live-video technique was found to be as effective as a conventional live demonstration for orthodontic practical education, suggesting that either technique could be used as an appropriate method for training in orthodontic wire bending.
本研究的目的在于评估一种现场视频教学工具对牙科学员弯曲正畸前庭弓性能的影响,并评估学生对该技术的看法。所有 135 名 2018 学年安卡拉哈塞特佩牙科学院的四年级牙科学员都被邀请参加这项研究;排除后,其余 116 名学员被随机分为两个示范组。这些学员以前没有弯曲正畸丝的经验。第 1 组(对照组,n=58)观看了传统的正畸前庭弓弯曲现场示范,第 2 组(实验组,n=58)观看了同一程序的现场视频示范。两组学员在开始练习前都观看了示范,并在练习后对其操作表现进行了评估。此外,还通过问卷调查收集了学生对示范技术的看法。结果显示,对照组和实验组学员的弯曲得分之间没有显著差异(p=0.767)。问卷的中位数值表明,两组学员的反应几乎没有统计学上的显著差异。唯一的显著差异是,第 1 组中回答“愿意”再次观看示范的学员比例高于第 2 组(p=0.024)。在这项研究中,现场视频技术被发现与传统的现场示范一样有效,可用于正畸实践教育,这表明这两种技术都可以作为正畸丝弯曲训练的合适方法。