Discipline of Speech Pathology, School of Allied Health, Human Services and Sport, La Trobe University, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
Centre of Research Excellence in Aphasia Recovery and Rehabilitation, Melbourne, Australia.
Int J Lang Commun Disord. 2024 Nov-Dec;59(6):2655-2670. doi: 10.1111/1460-6984.13106. Epub 2024 Aug 24.
People with communication disability after stroke experience low rates of return to vocational roles. Vocational rehabilitation is recommended; however, there are no clear guidelines informing vocational rehabilitation for people with communication disability. Understanding the needs and experiences of this population is critical to improving vocational stroke rehabilitation outcomes.
This study aimed to: (1) investigate the experience of vocational rehabilitation for people with communication disability after stroke, (2) identify gaps and, (3) provide preliminary recommendations for tailored service delivery.
Seven participants with an identified communication impairment following stroke were recruited from a larger clinical trial of early vocational rehabilitation (20% of total sample, n = 34). To address the study aims, a qualitative design was employed. Semi-structured, in-depth interviews were conducted and analysed using thematic analysis. Data were integrated with demographic and intervention audit data to contextualise participant experiences, identify vocational rehabilitation gaps and inform preliminary recommendations.
Participants were five men and two women aged 24-69 years whose communication profiles included difficulties with auditory comprehension and information processing, reading comprehension, thinking, executive function and self-regulation, as well as difficulties with verbal and written expression. Vocational rehabilitation was perceived as beneficial but participants identified gaps including limited access to psychological and peer-based support during early rehabilitation, limitations to accessing specialist vocational rehabilitation programs, barriers to accessing ongoing rehabilitation after resumption of vocational activity, and limited preparedness for the degree of impact that their communication changes had on execution of vocational roles and responsibilities.
Vocational environments are communicatively demanding and people living with acquired communication difficulties face a range of vocation-related participation barriers even when communication difficulties are mild. Greater emphasis on evaluating the vocational communication environment and targeted communication training and preparation for colleagues within the workplace is recommended to reduce barriers faced. Interdisciplinary rehabilitation, inclusive of psychological care, may support working-age stroke survivors to recognise and acknowledge changes in their communication function, lead to improved engagement in the rehabilitation process, and ensure early identification of factors likely to influence successful return-to-vocational activity.
What is already known on the subject Stroke is common amongst people of working age yet fewer than half of stroke survivors will return to pre-stroke vocational roles. Communication difficulties affect anywhere between 24% and 45% of people after stroke and include changes to language abilities, motor speech, vision, hearing and cognition. This group experiences much lower rates of return to vocational roles when compared to people with stroke who do not have a concomitant communication difficulty. Vocational rehabilitation is recommended. However, currently there is limited evidence to inform vocational rehabilitation guidelines for people with stroke and communication difficulties. Achieving a successful return to vocational activity is associated with improved life satisfaction for people with communication difficulties after stroke and is a key research priority for this population. What this study adds This study investigated the experiences of people with communication difficulty after stroke who reported a goal of returning to pre-stroke vocational activity. Data associated with types of interventions received, the experiences and perceptions of vocational rehabilitation, and experiences of returning to vocational activity were analysed to identify core rehabilitation needs and develop preliminary recommendations to inform future vocational rehabilitation guidelines for this population. What are the clinical implications of this work? The present study provides preliminary evidence that people experiencing communication difficulties after stroke require a more integrated rehabilitation pathway. During early stages of vocational rehabilitation psychological and peer-based support is indicated to support adjustment to changed communication function and to enable productive goal setting and engagement in rehabilitation. Clinicians need to complete a detailed analysis of the vocational communication environment and consider the communication activities involved in the individual's future vocational duties in order to plan meaningful rehabilitation. A multidisciplinary approach is required and additional training for clinicians is indicated to support clinicians to work collaboratively within the vocational setting.
患有中风后沟通障碍的人返回职业角色的比例较低。建议进行职业康复;然而,目前没有明确的指南来为有沟通障碍的人提供职业康复。了解这一人群的需求和经验对于改善职业中风康复结果至关重要。
本研究旨在:(1)调查中风后沟通障碍患者的职业康复体验,(2)确定差距,以及 (3)为量身定制的服务提供初步建议。
从一项早期职业康复的更大临床试验中(总样本的 20%,n=34)招募了 7 名有明确沟通障碍的中风患者。为了实现研究目标,采用了定性设计。进行了半结构化的深入访谈,并使用主题分析进行分析。将数据与人口统计学和干预审计数据相结合,以了解参与者的经验、确定职业康复差距,并为初步建议提供信息。
参与者为 5 名男性和 2 名女性,年龄在 24-69 岁之间,他们的沟通状况包括听觉理解和信息处理、阅读理解、思维、执行功能和自我调节方面的困难,以及言语和书面表达方面的困难。职业康复被认为是有益的,但参与者确定了一些差距,包括在早期康复期间有限获得心理和同伴支持,限制获得专门的职业康复计划,在恢复职业活动后获得持续康复的障碍,以及对他们的沟通变化对执行职业角色和责任的影响程度的准备有限。
职业环境对沟通要求很高,即使沟通困难轻微,患有获得性沟通障碍的人也面临一系列与职业相关的参与障碍。建议更加重视评估职业沟通环境,为同事提供有针对性的沟通培训和准备,以减少所面临的障碍。包括心理护理在内的跨学科康复可能有助于支持工作年龄的中风幸存者认识和承认他们的沟通功能的变化,促进他们积极参与康复过程,并确保早期确定可能影响成功重返职业活动的因素。
已知主题:中风在工作年龄人群中很常见,但只有不到一半的中风幸存者会恢复到中风前的职业角色。沟通障碍影响到中风后 24%至 45%的人,包括语言能力、运动言语、视力、听力和认知的变化。与没有伴随沟通障碍的中风患者相比,这一群体返回职业角色的比例要低得多。建议进行职业康复。然而,目前几乎没有证据为有中风和沟通障碍的患者提供职业康复指导方针。
本研究增加的内容:本研究调查了报告重返中风前职业活动目标的患有沟通障碍的中风患者的经历。分析了与所接受的干预类型、职业康复的经历和看法以及重返职业活动的经历相关的数据,以确定核心康复需求,并为这一人群制定初步建议,为未来的职业康复指南提供信息。
临床意义:本研究初步证明,患有中风后沟通障碍的人需要更综合的康复途径。在职业康复的早期阶段,需要提供心理和同伴支持,以支持对改变的沟通功能的调整,并使他们能够进行富有成效的目标设定和参与康复。临床医生需要对职业沟通环境进行详细分析,并考虑个体未来职业职责中涉及的沟通活动,以便规划有意义的康复。需要采取多学科方法,并为临床医生提供额外的培训,以支持临床医生在职业环境中进行协作。