University of Belgrade, Faculty of Philosophy, Institute of Ethnology and Anthropology, Čika Ljubina 18-20, office 4IEA/1, 11 000, Belgrade, Serbia.
Soc Sci Med. 2024 Oct;358:117225. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2024.117225. Epub 2024 Aug 15.
Rising vaccine hesitancy is often related to negative vaccination media coverage. It is generally accepted that the media played a great role in spreading the MMR (measles, mumps, and rubella) childhood vaccination scare first in the UK and then worldwide. During the COVID-19 pandemic, the MMR vaccination rate dropped further in some countries. This paper examines the Serbian news media framing of the MMR vaccination controversy in the period 2019-2023 (periods of declining MMR vaccination rate, rising COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy and the 2023 measles outbreaks). Furthermore, the paper questions whether the COVID-19 pandemic influenced the MMR vaccine narrative in the newspapers. For this reason, quality content analysis of the press in combination with framing approaches (diagnostic-prognostic-motivational framing tasks and responsibility framing) were used. In total, 122 articles dealing with the MMR vaccine and measles epidemics were analysed. According to the press, the most significant cause of the declining MMR rate is anti-vaccination campaigns and conspiracy theories by the "anti-vax lobby" (diagnostic frames). The pandemic was the other significant cause for the intake drop. Achieving herd immunity through vaccine uptake is offered as the best solution (prognostic frames). Finally, MMR vaccination campaigns and penalties for non-compliant parents and vaccine refusers are proposed as calls to action (motivational frames). During this period, the press did not publish any "sensational anti-vax stories". Considering the low MMR vaccine numbers in Serbia in this period, positive media messages did not have a significant influence on improving the vaccination rate. Thus, I suggest that Serbian parents distrust vaccination information presented by the dominant news, including the advice of health experts.
疫苗犹豫情绪上升通常与负面疫苗媒体报道有关。人们普遍认为,媒体在传播麻疹、腮腺炎和风疹(MMR)儿童疫苗恐慌方面发挥了巨大作用,首先在英国,然后在全球范围内传播。在 COVID-19 大流行期间,一些国家的 MMR 疫苗接种率进一步下降。本文研究了塞尔维亚新闻媒体在 2019-2023 年期间(MMR 疫苗接种率下降、COVID-19 疫苗犹豫情绪上升和 2023 年麻疹爆发期间)对 MMR 疫苗争议的报道框架。此外,本文还质疑 COVID-19 大流行是否影响了报纸上的 MMR 疫苗叙事。为此,采用了结合框架方法(诊断-预后-动机框架任务和责任框架)的新闻质量内容分析。总共分析了 122 篇涉及 MMR 疫苗和麻疹疫情的文章。根据新闻报道,MMR 接种率下降的最重要原因是反疫苗运动和“反疫苗游说”的阴谋论(诊断框架)。大流行是摄入下降的另一个重要原因。通过疫苗接种实现群体免疫被认为是最佳解决方案(预后框架)。最后,提出了 MMR 疫苗接种运动和对不遵守规定的父母和疫苗拒绝者的处罚作为行动呼吁(动机框架)。在此期间,媒体没有发布任何“耸人听闻的反疫苗故事”。考虑到塞尔维亚在此期间 MMR 疫苗数量较低,积极的媒体信息对提高疫苗接种率没有显著影响。因此,我建议塞尔维亚父母不信任主流新闻提供的疫苗接种信息,包括健康专家的建议。