Guo Beibei, Wang Li, Yuan Ying
Department of Experimental Statistics, Louisiana State University, Baton Rouge, LA 70803, USA.
Department of Statistics, AbbVie Inc., North Chicago, Illinois, U.S.A.
Stat Biopharm Res. 2024;16(3):361-370. doi: 10.1080/19466315.2023.2292238. Epub 2024 Jan 5.
An adaptive platform trial (APT) is a multi-arm trial in the context of a single disease where treatment arms are allowed to enter or leave the trial based on some decision rule. If a treatment enters the trial later than the control arm, there exist non-concurrent controls who were not randomized between the two arms under comparison. As APTs typically take long periods of time to conduct, temporal drift may occur, which requires the treatment comparisons to be adjusted for this temporal change. Under the causal inference framework, we propose two approaches for treatment comparisons in APTs that account for temporal drift, both based on propensity score weighting. In particular, to address unmeasured confounders, one approach is doubly robust in the sense that it remains valid so long as either the propensity score model is correctly specified or the time effect model is correctly specified. Simulation study shows that our proposed approaches have desirable operating characteristics with well controlled type I error rates and high power with or without unmeasured confounders.
适应性平台试验(APT)是针对单一疾病开展的多臂试验,其中各治疗组可依据某些决策规则加入或退出试验。如果一种治疗方法比对照组晚进入试验,那么就会存在非同期对照,即未在这两个对比组之间进行随机分组的对照。由于APT通常需要较长时间来实施,可能会出现时间漂移,这就要求针对这种时间变化对治疗比较进行调整。在因果推断框架下,我们基于倾向得分加权法,提出了两种在APT中考虑时间漂移的治疗比较方法。具体而言,为解决未测量的混杂因素问题,一种方法具有双重稳健性,即只要倾向得分模型或时间效应模型被正确设定,该方法就依然有效。模拟研究表明,我们提出的方法具有理想的操作特性,无论有无未测量的混杂因素,其I型错误率都能得到很好的控制,且检验效能较高。