Yuan Ying, Guo Beibei, Munsell Mark, Lu Karen, Jazaeri Amir
Department of Biostatistics, The University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center, Houston, TX, U.S.A.
Department of Experimental Statistics, Louisiana State University, Baton Rouge, LA, U.S.A.
Stat Med. 2016 Sep 30;35(22):3892-906. doi: 10.1002/sim.6971. Epub 2016 Apr 25.
Recent success of immunotherapy and other targeted therapies in cancer treatment has led to an unprecedented surge in the number of novel therapeutic agents that need to be evaluated in clinical trials. Traditional phase II clinical trial designs were developed for evaluating one candidate treatment at a time and thus not efficient for this task. We propose a Bayesian phase II platform design, the multi-candidate iterative design with adaptive selection (MIDAS), which allows investigators to continuously screen a large number of candidate agents in an efficient and seamless fashion. MIDAS consists of one control arm, which contains a standard therapy as the control, and several experimental arms, which contain the experimental agents. Patients are adaptively randomized to the control and experimental agents based on their estimated efficacy. During the trial, we adaptively drop inefficacious or overly toxic agents and 'graduate' the promising agents from the trial to the next stage of development. Whenever an experimental agent graduates or is dropped, the corresponding arm opens immediately for testing the next available new agent. Simulation studies show that MIDAS substantially outperforms the conventional approach. The proposed design yields a significantly higher probability for identifying the promising agents and dropping the futile agents. In addition, MIDAS requires only one master protocol, which streamlines trial conduct and substantially decreases the overhead burden. Copyright © 2016 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
免疫疗法和其他靶向疗法在癌症治疗中的近期成功,导致需要在临床试验中评估的新型治疗药物数量空前激增。传统的II期临床试验设计是为一次评估一种候选治疗方法而制定的,因此对于这项任务效率不高。我们提出了一种贝叶斯II期平台设计,即具有自适应选择的多候选迭代设计(MIDAS),它允许研究人员以高效且无缝的方式持续筛选大量候选药物。MIDAS由一个对照臂组成,该对照臂包含一种标准疗法作为对照,以及几个实验臂,这些实验臂包含实验药物。患者根据其估计疗效被自适应随机分配到对照药物和实验药物组。在试验期间,我们自适应地淘汰无效或毒性过大的药物,并将有前景的药物从试验“推进”到下一阶段的开发。每当一种实验药物被推进或淘汰时,相应的臂会立即开放用于测试下一种可用的新药。模拟研究表明,MIDAS显著优于传统方法。所提出的设计在识别有前景的药物和淘汰无效药物方面具有显著更高的概率。此外,MIDAS只需要一个主方案,这简化了试验实施并大幅减轻了管理负担。版权所有© 2016约翰威立父子有限公司。