Division of the National Health Laboratory Service, National Institute for Communicable Diseases, Centre for Enteric Diseases, Johannesburg, South Africa.
Faculty of Health Sciences, Department of Medical Microbiology, School of Medicine, University of Pretoria, Pretoria, South Africa.
PLoS One. 2024 Aug 26;19(8):e0309409. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0309409. eCollection 2024.
Our 24-month study used metagenomics to investigate antimicrobial resistance (AMR) abundance in raw sewage from wastewater treatment works (WWTWs) in two municipalities in Gauteng Province, South Africa. At the AMR class level, data showed similar trends at all WWTWs, showing that aminoglycoside, beta-lactam, sulfonamide and tetracycline resistance was most abundant. AMR abundance differences were shown between municipalities, where Tshwane Metropolitan Municipality (TMM) WWTWs showed overall higher abundance of AMR compared to Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality (EMM) WWTWs. Also, within each municipality, there were differing trends in AMR abundance. Notably, within TMM, certain AMR classes (macrolides and macrolides_streptogramin B) were in higher abundance at a WWTW serving an urban high-income area, while other AMR classes (aminoglycosides) were in higher abundance at a WWTW serving a semi-urban low income area. At the AMR gene level, all WWTWs samples showed the most abundance for the sul1 gene (encoding sulfonamide resistance). Following this, the next 14 most abundant genes encoded resistance to sulfonamides, aminoglycosides, macrolides, tetracyclines and beta-lactams. Notably, within TMM, some macrolide-encoding resistance genes (mefC, msrE, mphG and mphE) were in highest abundance at a WWTW serving an urban high-income area; while sul1, sul2 and tetC genes were in highest abundance at a WWTW serving a semi-urban low income area. Differential abundance analysis of AMR genes at WWTWs, following stratification of data by season, showed some notable variance in six AMR genes, of which blaKPC-2 and blaKPC-34 genes showed the highest prevalence of seasonal abundance differences when comparing data within a WWTW. The general trend was to see higher abundances of AMR genes in colder seasons, when comparing seasonal data within a WWTW. Our study investigated wastewater samples in only one province of South Africa, from WWTWs located within close proximity to one another. We would require a more widespread investigation at WWTWs distributed across all regions/provinces of South Africa, in order to describe a more comprehensive profile of AMR abundance across the country.
我们的 24 个月研究使用宏基因组学来调查南非豪登省两个市的污水处理厂(WWTWs)的原始污水中的抗生素耐药性(AMR)丰度。在 AMR 类别水平上,数据显示所有 WWTWs 均显示出相似的趋势,表明氨基糖苷类、β-内酰胺类、磺胺类和四环素类耐药性最为丰富。市与市之间的 AMR 丰度存在差异,其中茨瓦内都会市区(TMM)的 WWTWs 显示出的 AMR 丰度总体高于伊库鲁莱尼都会市区(EMM)的 WWTWs。此外,在每个市中,AMR 丰度也存在不同的趋势。值得注意的是,在 TMM 中,某些 AMR 类别(大环内酯类和大环内酯类-林可酰胺 B)在服务于城市高收入地区的 WWTW 中丰度较高,而其他 AMR 类别(氨基糖苷类)在服务于半城市低收入地区的 WWTW 中丰度较高。在 AMR 基因水平上,所有 WWTWs 样本均显示出 sul1 基因(编码磺胺类耐药性)的最高丰度。紧随其后的是接下来 14 个最丰富的基因,编码对磺胺类、氨基糖苷类、大环内酯类、四环素类和β-内酰胺类的耐药性。值得注意的是,在 TMM 中,一些大环内酯类耐药基因(mefC、msrE、mphG 和 mphE)在服务于城市高收入地区的 WWTW 中丰度最高;而 sul1、sul2 和 tetC 基因在服务于半城市低收入地区的 WWTW 中丰度最高。对 WWTWs 的 AMR 基因进行分层数据的季节差异分析后,发现六个 AMR 基因中有一些明显的差异,其中 blaKPC-2 和 blaKPC-34 基因在比较 WWTW 内的数据时显示出最高的季节性丰度差异。一般趋势是,在比较 WWTW 内的季节性数据时,寒冷季节的 AMR 基因丰度更高。我们的研究仅在南非的一个省调查了废水样本,来自彼此接近的 WWTWs。为了更全面地描述整个国家的 AMR 丰度概况,我们需要在南非所有地区/省份的 WWTWs 中进行更广泛的调查。