Sahitia Sundeep, Idris Idayu Badilla, Safian Nazarudin, Ali Rozina F, Shamsuddin Khadijah, Hod Rozita
Department of Public Health Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, Cheras, Malaysia.
DKT Pakistan, Karachi, Pakistan.
Qual Health Res. 2025 Mar;35(3):349-365. doi: 10.1177/10497323241263279. Epub 2024 Aug 27.
Despite overall improvements observed at the national level, there is a significant disparity in childhood vaccination coverage rates between urban and rural regions, particularly within tribal and remote areas in Pakistan. Our study aimed to explore the views of community/tribal leaders concerning barriers and their local solutions for improving vaccine uptake, with a specific focus on remote settings. An exploratory qualitative research study was conducted from July to September 2019 in Shikarpur, Sindh, Pakistan. We interviewed 11 community leaders, after developing a semi-structured interview guide based on the health belief model. Following validation, the collected data was transcribed and subsequently translated into the English language. A stepwise process of manual familiarization, coding, theme generation, and theme review using an inductive approach was followed. While most of the rural community leaders expressed a willingness to support vaccinations, numerous unexplored barriers were identified. These barriers included an unsustainable communication system heavily dependent on polio mobile teams, discourteous behavior of healthcare personnel, cultural restrictions that limited women's involvement, economic hardships, limited transportation options, insufficient collaboration with the education sector, poor knowledge among community leaders, and security concerns. Additionally, they proposed some innovative solutions of information dissemination methods through the Ottaque system, ethics-based training, subsidized transportation services or voucher system, and addressing security concerns in collaboration with community leaders. Our findings suggest policymakers take both community leaders and members for an inclusive policy-making process to redraft the special policy for these remote and rural areas.
尽管在国家层面上观察到了总体改善,但巴基斯坦城乡地区,特别是部落地区和偏远地区的儿童疫苗接种覆盖率存在显著差异。我们的研究旨在探讨社区/部落领袖对改善疫苗接种率的障碍及其当地解决方案的看法,特别关注偏远地区。2019年7月至9月在巴基斯坦信德省希卡普尔进行了一项探索性定性研究。在基于健康信念模型制定了半结构化访谈指南后,我们采访了11位社区领袖。经过验证后,对收集到的数据进行了转录,随后翻译成英语。采用归纳法,遵循了人工熟悉、编码、主题生成和主题审查的逐步过程。虽然大多数农村社区领袖表示愿意支持疫苗接种,但仍发现了许多未被探索的障碍。这些障碍包括严重依赖脊灰流动团队的不可持续的通信系统、医护人员的无礼行为、限制妇女参与的文化限制、经济困难、交通选择有限、与教育部门的合作不足、社区领袖知识匮乏以及安全担忧。此外,他们还提出了一些创新的信息传播方法解决方案,如通过奥托克系统、基于道德的培训、补贴交通服务或代金券系统,以及与社区领袖合作解决安全担忧。我们的研究结果表明,政策制定者应让社区领袖和成员参与包容性的政策制定过程,以重新制定针对这些偏远农村地区的特殊政策。