Gadapani Pathak Barsha, Mazumder Sarmila, Bin Nisar Yasir, Bhatt Aditya, Singh Mandeep, Madhur Tarun, Sandøy Ingvild Fossgard
Society for Applied Studies, New Delhi, India.
Centre for Intervention Science in Maternal and Child Health, Centre for International Health, Department of Global Public Health and Primary Care, University of Bergen, Bergen, Norway.
Health Expect. 2025 Apr;28(2):e70263. doi: 10.1111/hex.70263.
Pneumonia is a leading cause of under-five mortality, with 30 million annual cases in India. Despite national guidelines, significant barriers to timely and appropriate care-seeking persist. Caregivers often face financial constraints, lack of awareness, mistrust in government facilities and a preference for non-registered medical practitioners (non-RMPs), delaying effective treatment. This study explores care-seeking behaviours, associated socio-demographic factors and barriers to access to appropriate healthcare for childhood pneumonia in rural India.
This study is part of a broader implementation research (IR) initiative and represents its formative phase. This mixed-methods study was conducted in Palwal district, Haryana, covering 42 villages (population: 107,440). A cross-sectional survey identified suspected pneumonia cases among 9593 under-five children through house-to-house visits using a structured checklist. Data on socio-demographic characteristics, health insurance, care-seeking patterns and provider preferences were collected. Directed acyclic graphs (DAGs) identified potential confounders in the association between care-seeking behaviour and key exposure variables. Additionally, qualitative in-depth interviews explored caregivers' perceptions, decision-making and healthcare barriers to pneumonia management. Quantitative data were analysed using logistic regression, while qualitative data were thematically analysed using the Three Delays Model. Suspected under-five pneumonia cases' caregivers and families were actively engaged in this formative phase to inform Phase II implementation strategies of broader IR, ensuring community-driven and contextually relevant strategies.
Among 231 suspected pneumonia cases, 97% of caregivers sought medical care, but 71% consulted non-RMPs, and only 3.6% visited government facilities. Seeking appropriate care was associated with higher maternal education (AOR 6.5, 95% CI: 2.7-9.7) and higher wealth index (AOR 1.7, 95% CI: 1.0-2.6). Thematic analysis revealed delays due to symptom misinterpretation, reliance on home remedies, financial constraints, gender biases, mistrust in public healthcare services and logistical barriers.
Despite high care-seeking rates, provider preferences, socio-cultural factors and systemic barriers delay appropriate pneumonia treatment. Addressing these challenges requires improving awareness, enhancing public healthcare trust and strengthening frontline healthworker engagement. This study underscores the role of structured beneficiary involvement in refining pneumonia management strategies to ensure sustainable, community-driven interventions.
This study is part of an ongoing implementation research (IR) aimed at improving the effective coverage of childhood pneumonia management in a low-resource setting. A structured engagement with primary caregivers of under-five children, mothers, fathers, family members, community members and local community stakeholders/representatives, for example, local leaders, village heads and so forth, has been integrated at multiple stages to ensure the relevance and applicability of its findings. The current study is part of Phase I (formative research) of the IR, where primary caregivers and family members participated in a needs assessment, providing critical insights into the barriers and facilitators influencing care-seeking for childhood pneumonia in a rural low-to-middle socio-economic setting. Their inputs have informed the refinement of study tools and the development of mitigation strategies for the logic and implementation model. As the research progresses into Phase II (model development and implementation), the community continues to play an integral role in providing feedback on the feasibility and appropriateness of proposed strategies. This ongoing feedback loop assesses how effectively these strategies strengthen linkages between the healthcare system and the community, foster an active local needs assessment mechanism among healthcare providers and enhance demand generation for appropriate pneumonia care-seeking. These iterative refinements ensure that the implementation strategies remain responsive to the evolving needs of the community. In the forthcoming Phase III, which will focus on scaling up the finalised implementation model, strategies will be adapted to further improve care-seeking for under-five children. Continuous engagement with caregivers and local community representatives, including Panchayati Raj Institution (PRI) members, will be central to refining these strategies. Additionally, during the dissemination phase, key findings will be shared with caregivers, community members and PRI representatives, facilitating discussions on study implications and informing future policy and programmatic decisions. Their ongoing involvement will help contextualise findings and enhance the long-term sustainability of strategies aimed at improving pneumonia care-seeking behaviours and effective management in rural India.
肺炎是五岁以下儿童死亡的主要原因,印度每年有3000万例肺炎病例。尽管有国家指南,但及时寻求适当治疗仍存在重大障碍。照顾者常常面临经济限制、缺乏认识、对政府医疗机构不信任以及偏爱未注册的医生(非注册医生),从而延误了有效治疗。本研究探讨了印度农村地区儿童肺炎患者寻求治疗的行为、相关的社会人口因素以及获得适当医疗保健的障碍。
本研究是一项更广泛的实施研究(IR)倡议的一部分,代表其形成阶段。这项混合方法研究在哈里亚纳邦帕尔瓦尔区进行,涵盖42个村庄(人口:107440)。通过使用结构化清单逐户走访,在9593名五岁以下儿童中识别出疑似肺炎病例。收集了关于社会人口特征、健康保险、寻求治疗模式和提供者偏好的数据。有向无环图(DAGs)确定了寻求治疗行为与关键暴露变量之间关联中的潜在混杂因素。此外,定性深入访谈探讨了照顾者对肺炎管理的看法、决策和医疗保健障碍。定量数据采用逻辑回归分析,而定性数据采用“三个延误模型”进行主题分析。五岁以下疑似肺炎病例的照顾者和家庭积极参与了这个形成阶段,为更广泛的实施研究的第二阶段实施策略提供信息,确保以社区为驱动且符合实际情况的策略。
在231例疑似肺炎病例中,97%的照顾者寻求了医疗护理,但71%咨询了非注册医生,只有3.6%前往政府医疗机构就诊。寻求适当治疗与母亲受教育程度较高(调整后比值比[AOR]6.5,95%置信区间[CI]:2.7 - 9.7)和财富指数较高(AOR 1.7,95% CI:1.0 - 2.6)相关。主题分析揭示了由于症状误解、依赖家庭疗法、经济限制、性别偏见、对公共医疗服务不信任以及后勤障碍导致的延误。
尽管寻求治疗的比例很高,但提供者偏好、社会文化因素和系统性障碍延误了适当的肺炎治疗。应对这些挑战需要提高认识、增强对公共医疗保健的信任并加强一线卫生工作者的参与。本研究强调了结构化的受益者参与在完善肺炎管理策略以确保可持续的、以社区为驱动的干预措施方面的作用。
本研究是一项正在进行的实施研究(IR)的一部分,旨在提高资源匮乏环境下儿童肺炎管理的有效覆盖率。在多个阶段都与五岁以下儿童的主要照顾者、母亲、父亲、家庭成员、社区成员以及当地社区利益相关者/代表(例如当地领导人、村长等)进行了结构化的互动,以确保研究结果的相关性和适用性。当前研究是实施研究第一阶段(形成性研究)的一部分,主要照顾者和家庭成员参与了需求评估,对影响农村中低社会经济环境下儿童肺炎寻求治疗的障碍和促进因素提供了关键见解。他们的意见为研究工具的完善以及逻辑和实施模型的缓解策略的制定提供了参考。随着研究进展到第二阶段(模型开发与实施),社区在对拟议策略的可行性和适当性提供反馈方面继续发挥不可或缺的作用。这个持续的反馈循环评估这些策略在加强医疗保健系统与社区之间的联系、在医疗保健提供者中促进积极的当地需求评估机制以及增强对适当肺炎治疗寻求的需求生成方面的效果如何。这些迭代改进确保实施策略能够持续响应社区不断变化的需求。在即将到来的第三阶段,将专注于扩大最终确定的实施模型,策略将进行调整以进一步改善五岁以下儿童的治疗寻求情况。与照顾者和当地社区代表(包括乡村自治机构[PRI]成员)的持续互动对于完善这些策略至关重要。此外,在传播阶段,关键研究结果将与照顾者、社区成员和PRI代表分享,促进关于研究影响的讨论,并为未来的政策和项目决策提供信息。他们的持续参与将有助于使研究结果更符合实际情况,并提高旨在改善印度农村地区肺炎治疗寻求行为和有效管理的策略的长期可持续性。