Schmeling Andreas, Fracasso Tony
Institute of Legal Medicine, Münster, Germany.
Centre Universitaire Romand de Médicine Légale (CURML), Geneva, Switzerland.
Int J Legal Med. 2025 Jan;139(1):285-291. doi: 10.1007/s00414-024-03310-3. Epub 2024 Aug 28.
A questionnaire was prepared in advance of the 26th triennial conference of the International Academy of Legal Medicine (IALM) and sent to 474 email addresses included in the IALM mailing list. The questionnaire addressed three current challenges faced by the International Journal of Legal Medicine (IJLM): the publication of guidelines and validation studies in the field of legal medicine, the publication ethics of case reports, and the recruitment of new reviewers for the IJLM. The response rate was 20%. The survey results highlight the need for international guidelines in various areas of legal medicine. Some desired guidelines already exist. To provide visibility and knowledge of the existing national guidelines, the IJLM has launched a Topical Collection on Quality Assurance in Legal Medicine. This collection aims to inform readers about country-specific characteristics of legal medicine structures and the existing national guidelines.Around 80% of the participants stated that there are legal or ethical requirements for the publication of forensic case reports or case series. Various options for obtaining consent for publication are discussed. Eighty-six of the 97 participants indicated their willingness to review manuscripts for the IJLM. It is emphasized that the contributions of reviewers should be duly recognized and valued.
在国际法律医学学会(IALM)第26届三年一度会议召开之前,准备了一份调查问卷,并发送至IALM邮件列表中的474个电子邮箱地址。该问卷涉及《国际法律医学杂志》(IJLM)当前面临的三个挑战:法医学领域指南及验证研究的发表、病例报告的发表伦理,以及为IJLM招募新的审稿人。回复率为20%。调查结果凸显了法医学各领域制定国际指南的必要性。一些所需指南已然存在。为了提高现有国家指南的知名度并增进对其的了解,IJLM推出了一个关于法医学质量保证的专题文集。该文集旨在让读者了解法医学结构的国别特点以及现有的国家指南。约80%的参与者表示,法医病例报告或病例系列的发表存在法律或伦理要求。文中讨论了获得发表同意的各种方式。97名参与者中有86人表示愿意为IJLM审阅稿件。强调审稿人的贡献应得到充分认可和重视。