Benaim Ezer H, O'Rourke Samuel P, Dillon Margaret T
Department of Otolaryngology/Head and Neck Surgery, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, North Carolina, U.S.A.
Laryngoscope. 2025 Feb;135(2):840-847. doi: 10.1002/lary.31741. Epub 2024 Aug 27.
Identify the questions most frequently asked online about cochlear implants (CI) and assess the readability and quality of the content.
A Google search engine observational study was conducted via a search response optimization (SEO) tool. The SEO tool listed the questions generated by Google's "People Also Ask" (PAA) feature for the search queries "cochlear implant" and "cochlear implant surgery." The top 50 PAA questions for each query were conceptually classified. Sourced websites were evaluated for readability, transparency and information quality, and ability to answer the question. Readability and accuracy in answering questions were also compared to the responses from ChatGPT 3.5.
The PAA questions were commonly related to technical details (21%), surgical factors (18%), and postoperative experiences (12%). Sourced websites mainly were from academic institutions, followed by commercial companies. Among all types of websites, readability, on average, did not meet the recommended standard for health-related patient education materials. Only two websites were at or below the 8th-grade level. Responses by ChatGPT had significantly poorer readability compared to the websites (p < 0.001). These online resources were not significantly different in the percentage of accurately answering the questions (websites: 78%, ChatGPT: 85%, p = 0.136).
The most searched topics were technical details about devices, surgical factors, and the postoperative experience. Unfortunately, most websites did not meet the ideal criteria of readability, quality, and credibility for patient education. These results highlight potential knowledge gaps for patients, deficits in current online education materials, and possible tools to better support CI candidate decision-making.
NA Laryngoscope, 135:840-847, 2025.
确定在线上关于人工耳蜗(CI)最常被问到的问题,并评估内容的可读性和质量。
通过搜索响应优化(SEO)工具进行谷歌搜索引擎观察性研究。该SEO工具列出了谷歌“人们也问”(PAA)功能针对搜索查询“人工耳蜗”和“人工耳蜗手术”生成的问题。对每个查询的前50个PAA问题进行概念分类。对来源网站的可读性、透明度、信息质量以及回答问题的能力进行评估。还将回答问题的可读性和准确性与ChatGPT 3.5的回答进行比较。
PAA问题通常与技术细节(21%)、手术因素(18%)和术后体验(12%)相关。来源网站主要来自学术机构,其次是商业公司。在所有类型的网站中,平均可读性未达到与健康相关的患者教育材料的推荐标准。只有两个网站达到或低于八年级水平。与网站相比,ChatGPT的回答可读性明显较差(p < 0.001)。这些在线资源在准确回答问题的百分比方面没有显著差异(网站:78%,ChatGPT:85%,p = 0.136)。
搜索最多的主题是设备的技术细节、手术因素和术后体验。不幸的是,大多数网站在患者教育的可读性、质量和可信度方面未达到理想标准。这些结果凸显了患者潜在的知识差距、当前在线教育材料的不足以及可能有助于更好地支持人工耳蜗候选者决策的工具。
无 喉镜,135:840 - 847,2025年。