Ding Xibing, Jin Shuqing, Tian Weitian, Zhang Yizhe, Xu Li, Zhang Tong, Chen Zhixia, Niu Fangfang, Li Quan
Department of Anesthesiology, Renji Hospital, Shanghai Jiaotong University School of Medicine, Shanghai, China.
Department of Anesthesiology, Shanghai Pulmonary Hospital, Tongji University, Shanghai, China.
Shock. 2025 Feb 1;63(2):299-311. doi: 10.1097/SHK.0000000000002471. Epub 2024 Sep 4.
Background: Mechanical ventilation (MV) is a clinically important measure for respiratory support in critically ill patients. Although moderate tidal volume MV does not cause lung injury, it can further exacerbate lung injury in a pathological state such as sepsis. This pathological process is known as the "two-hit" theory, whereby an initial lung injury (e.g., infection, trauma, or sepsis) triggers an inflammatory response that activates immune cells, presenting the lung tissue in a fragile state and rendering it more susceptible to subsequent injury. The second hit occurs when MV is applied to lung tissue in a fragile state, and it is noteworthy that this MV is harmless to healthy lung tissue, further aggravating preexisting lung injury through unknown mechanisms. This interaction between initial injury and subsequent MV develops a malignant cycle significantly exacerbating lung injury and severely hampering patient prognosis. The two-hit theory is critical to understanding the complicated mechanisms of ventilator-associated lung injury and facilitates the subsequent development of targeted therapeutic strategies. Methods and Results: The cecum ligation and perforation mice model was used to mimic clinical sepsis patients. After 12 h, the mice were mechanically ventilated for 2 to 6 h. MV by itself did not lead to HMGB1 release, but significantly strengthened HMGB1 in plasma and cytoplasm of lung tissue in septic mice. Plasma and lung tissue activation of cytokines and chemokines, mitogen-activated protein kinase signaling pathway, neutrophil recruitment, and acute lung injury were progressively decreased in LysM HMGB1 -/- (Hmgb1 deletion in myeloid cells) and iHMGB1 -/- mice (inducible HMGB1 -/- mouse strain where the Hmgb1 gene was globally deleted after tamoxifen treatment). Compared with C57BL/6 mice, although EC-HMGB1 -/- (Hmgb1 deletion in endothelial cells) mice did not have lower levels of inflammation, neutrophil recruitment and lung injury were reduced. Compared with LysM HMGB1 -/- mice, EC-HMGB1 -/- mice had higher levels of inflammation but significantly lower neutrophil recruitment and lung injury. Overall, iHMGB1 -/- mice had the lowest levels of all the above indicators. The level of inflammation, neutrophil recruitment, and the degree of lung injury were decreased in RAGE -/- mice, and even the above indices were further decreased in TLR4/RAGE -/- mice. Levels of inflammation and neutrophil recruitment were decreased in caspase-11 -/- and caspase-1/11 -/- mice, but there was no statistical difference between these two gene knockout mice. Conclusions: These data show for the first time that the caspase-1/caspase-11-HMGB1-TLR4/RAGE signaling pathway plays a key role in mice model of sepsis-induced lung injury exacerbated by MV. Different species of HMGB1 knockout mice have different lung-protective mechanisms in the two-hit model, and location is the key to function. Specifically, LysM HMGB1 -/- mice due to the deletion of HMGB1 in myeloid cells resulted in a pulmonary-protective mechanism that was associated with a downregulation of the inflammatory response. EC-HMGB1 -/- mice are deficient in HMGB1 owing to endothelial cells, resulting in a distinct pulmonary-protective mechanism independent of the inflammatory response and more relevant to the improvement of alveolar-capillary permeability. iHMGB1 -/- mice, which are systemically HMGB1-deficient, share both of these lung-protective mechanisms.
机械通气(MV)是危重症患者呼吸支持的一项重要临床措施。尽管适度潮气量的机械通气不会导致肺损伤,但在脓毒症等病理状态下,它会进一步加重肺损伤。这一病理过程被称为“两次打击”理论,即初始肺损伤(如感染、创伤或脓毒症)引发炎症反应,激活免疫细胞,使肺组织处于脆弱状态,更容易受到后续损伤。第二次打击发生在对处于脆弱状态的肺组织应用机械通气时,值得注意的是,这种机械通气对健康肺组织无害,但通过未知机制进一步加重了已有的肺损伤。初始损伤与后续机械通气之间的这种相互作用形成了一个恶性循环,显著加重肺损伤并严重阻碍患者预后。“两次打击”理论对于理解呼吸机相关性肺损伤的复杂机制至关重要,并有助于后续针对性治疗策略的发展。
采用盲肠结扎穿孔小鼠模型模拟临床脓毒症患者。12小时后,对小鼠进行2至6小时的机械通气。机械通气本身不会导致高迁移率族蛋白B1(HMGB1)释放,但会显著增强脓毒症小鼠血浆和肺组织细胞质中的HMGB1。在髓系细胞中Hmgb1基因缺失的LysM HMGB1 -/-小鼠和诱导型HMGB1 -/-小鼠(他莫昔芬治疗后Hmgb1基因在整体上被缺失的诱导型HMGB1 -/-小鼠品系)中,细胞因子、趋化因子的血浆和肺组织激活、丝裂原活化蛋白激酶信号通路、中性粒细胞募集及急性肺损伤逐渐减少。与C57BL/6小鼠相比,虽然内皮细胞中Hmgb1基因缺失的EC-HMGB1 -/-小鼠炎症水平没有降低,但中性粒细胞募集和肺损伤减少。与LysM HMGB1 -/-小鼠相比,EC-HMGB1 -/-小鼠炎症水平较高,但中性粒细胞募集和肺损伤显著降低。总体而言,诱导型HMGB1 -/-小鼠上述所有指标水平最低。在晚期糖基化终末产物受体(RAGE)-/-小鼠中,炎症水平、中性粒细胞募集及肺损伤程度降低,在Toll样受体4(TLR4)/RAGE -/-小鼠中,上述指标甚至进一步降低。在半胱天冬酶-11(caspase-11)-/-和半胱天冬酶-1/11(caspase-1/11)-/-小鼠中,炎症水平和中性粒细胞募集降低,但这两种基因敲除小鼠之间无统计学差异。
这些数据首次表明,半胱天冬酶-1/半胱天冬酶-11-HMGB1-TLR4/RAGE信号通路在机械通气加重的脓毒症诱导的小鼠肺损伤模型中起关键作用。在“两次打击”模型中,不同种类的HMGB1基因敲除小鼠具有不同的肺保护机制,而位置是功能的关键。具体而言,髓系细胞中HMGB1基因缺失的LysM HMGB1 -/-小鼠产生了一种与炎症反应下调相关的肺保护机制。内皮细胞中HMGB1基因缺失的EC-HMGB1 -/-小鼠由于内皮细胞缺乏HMGB1,产生了一种独立于炎症反应且与改善肺泡-毛细血管通透性更相关的独特肺保护机制。全身HMGB1基因缺失的诱导型HMGB1 -/-小鼠兼具这两种肺保护机制。