Varricchio Attilio, Presutti Livio, La Mantia Ignazio, Ciprandi Giorgio
1Department of Otolaryngology, University of Molise, Campobasso, Italy.
ENT Department, University of Bologna, Italy.
Multidiscip Respir Med. 2024 Sep 4;19(1):991. doi: 10.5826/mrm.2024.991.
Topical nasal therapy is widely used in clinical practice by different specialists. However, it is multifaceted and still controversial. Namely, there is no consensus about the many aspects, and there needs to be specific guidelines. Four independent experts involved 14 Italian scientific societies (concerning ENT, allergy, and pediatrics areas) to participate in generating an Intersocietal Delphi Consensus on this matter. Three iterative rounds collected experts (4 in the first round, 20 in the second round, and 45 in the third round) designed by the scientific societies based on their clinical expertise and documented scientific value. Thirty-four statements were discussed and voted on. At the second round, all statements accomplished a very high consensus grade (>95%). At the third round, many statements reached a high or very high grade of consensus (>70%). However, some statements did not obtain sufficient agreement. Consequently, there is a need to implement knowledge about this issue through educational initiatives and new studies conducted with a robust methodology. In conclusion, topical nasal therapy deserves adequate knowledge as it is widespread and fruitful in managing upper respiratory diseases.
局部鼻腔治疗在临床实践中被不同专科医生广泛应用。然而,它是多方面的且仍存在争议。也就是说,在许多方面没有达成共识,需要有具体的指导方针。四位独立专家邀请了14个意大利科学学会(涉及耳鼻喉科、过敏和儿科领域)参与就此事达成跨学会德尔菲共识。三轮迭代收集了由科学学会根据其临床专业知识和文献科学价值挑选的专家(第一轮4位,第二轮20位,第三轮45位)。对34条陈述进行了讨论和投票。在第二轮,所有陈述都达成了非常高的共识等级(>95%)。在第三轮,许多陈述达到了高或非常高的共识等级(>70%)。然而,一些陈述没有获得足够的认同。因此,有必要通过教育举措和采用强有力方法进行的新研究来增进对这个问题的了解。总之,局部鼻腔治疗在管理上呼吸道疾病方面广泛且有效,值得有充分的认识。