Eramian Laura, Mallory Peter, Herbert Morgan
Department of Sociology and Social Anthropology, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada.
Department of Sociology, St. Francis Xavier University, Antigonish, Nova Scotia, Canada.
Can Rev Sociol. 2025 Feb;62(1):99-117. doi: 10.1111/cars.12484. Epub 2024 Sep 4.
This article is based on 21 interviews in an Atlantic Canadian city with people who identified as having few or no friends. With all the talk of a modern loneliness epidemic, we might easily assume friendless people are lonely, yet here we take an interpretive approach to analyze how they alternately claim to experience and not experience loneliness. We argue that claims to loneliness or its absence are never merely personal stories or problems of individual health or wellbeing, but are shaped by larger cultural resources and meanings. We found that friendless people both lament and celebrate their disconnection, a duality that we theorize through competing views of the modern self as both autonomous/self-reliant and fundamentally in need of connection and community. We show how our interviewees struggle to find meaning in their disconnection and self-respect in a society where being friendless is open to stigma or pity.
本文基于对加拿大大西洋沿岸一座城市中21位自称朋友很少或几乎没有朋友的人的访谈。在关于现代孤独流行的种种讨论中,我们可能很容易认为没有朋友的人会感到孤独,但在这里,我们采用一种解释性方法来分析他们如何时而声称体验到孤独,时而又声称没有体验到孤独。我们认为,对孤独或不孤独的宣称绝不仅仅是个人故事或个人健康或幸福的问题,而是由更广泛的文化资源和意义塑造的。我们发现,没有朋友的人既哀叹又庆祝他们的与世隔绝,这种二元性我们通过现代自我的两种相互竞争的观点来进行理论化,即现代自我既是自主/自力更生的,又从根本上需要联系和社群。我们展示了我们的受访者如何在一个没有朋友会遭人非议或怜悯的社会中,努力在他们的与世隔绝中找到意义并维护自尊。