Department of Philosophy, Sociology, Pedagogy and Applied Psychology (FISPPA), University of Padova, Padova, Italy.
Health Expect. 2024 Oct;27(5):e14148. doi: 10.1111/hex.14148.
The WHO European Mental Health Action Plan (2013-2030) emphasises the need to generate services that are more inclusive and attentive to the co-construction of care practices. This exploratory research investigates the needs of young substance abusers shown during their stay in residential communities; in particular, it explores the idea that treatment may include a new phase focused on how to manage moderate or controlled alcohol intake during residential care. Interviews with young ex-users open up critical reflections on complete abstinence programmes from all substances, including alcohol, as a prerequisite for discharge and also provide examples of how to co-design a plan for mindful drinking.
Fourteen young adults, aged 19-32 years, non-alcoholists, treated at rehab in Fermo, in central Italy, were interviewed during a programme between 6 and 18 months of period. They were asked about exploring needs in preparation for the conclusion of the rehabilitation pathway. From this exploration emerged the need to introduce controlled alcohol intake during the rehabilitation stay. This request became the focus of the semi-structured interviews.
Three main themes emerged, which are as follows: (1) difficulties in integrating the new identity with the past of consumption, (2) resistance to the idea of total abstinence in social relations and (3) uncertainties about post-community behaviour regarding alcohol intake. At the same time, three unexpected needs were expressed: (1) test the personal knowledge and skills on how to manage the alcohol intake, (2) receive support during the residential path to build up self-control competence given the post-discharge period and (3) build a personalised therapeutic path together with the supervisor and the operators while still at the rehab, according to the realistic lifestyle and routine outside the rehab.
This research highlights the importance of personalising treatment based on each user's needs, going far beyond the standardised treatments for users previously considered unable of self-control and self-determination. For that purpose, the relationship between the users and the operators might be privileged, as it is able to cover the specific needs aimed for the new identity.
The research sparked a discussion within the community, involving and initiating an open dialogue between the operators and the users, allowing them to focus on certain innovative strategies offered by the service, putting the users' needs at the very centre of the attention. The results were compared and discussed actively with the participants involved.
世界卫生组织欧洲心理健康行动计划(2013-2030 年)强调需要提供更具包容性且注重共同构建护理实践的服务。本探索性研究调查了在居住社区中接受治疗的年轻物质滥用者的需求;特别是,它探讨了治疗可能包括一个新的阶段,重点是如何在居住护理期间管理适度或受控的饮酒量。对年轻前使用者的访谈对完全戒除所有物质(包括酒精)的方案提出了批判性反思,这是出院的前提条件,同时也提供了如何共同设计正念饮酒计划的示例。
14 名年龄在 19-32 岁之间的非酗酒年轻人在意大利中部费尔莫的康复中心接受治疗,在 6 至 18 个月的项目期间接受了访谈。他们被要求探讨为康复途径结束做准备时的需求。从这次探索中出现了在康复期间引入受控饮酒量的需求。这个需求成为了半结构化访谈的焦点。
出现了三个主要主题,如下所示:(1)在新身份与过去消费之间融合的困难,(2)在社会关系中对完全戒除的想法的抵制,以及(3)对社区后行为关于饮酒的不确定性。与此同时,表达了三个意外的需求:(1)测试个人关于如何管理饮酒量的知识和技能,(2)在住宅期间获得支持,以建立自我控制能力,因为在出院后,(3)在康复中心与主管和工作人员一起制定个性化的治疗方案,根据康复中心外的现实生活方式和常规。
这项研究强调了根据每个用户的需求个性化治疗的重要性,远远超出了之前被认为无法自我控制和自我决定的用户的标准化治疗。为此,用户与运营商之间的关系可能会受到青睐,因为它能够满足新身份的特定需求。
该研究在社区内引发了讨论,涉及并启动了运营商和用户之间的公开对话,使他们能够专注于服务提供的某些创新策略,将用户的需求置于关注的中心。研究结果与参与的参与者进行了比较和积极讨论。