Department of Aerospace and Geodesy, Technical University of Munich, 80333, Munich, Germany.
The College of Geography and Environment Science, Henan University, Kaifeng, 475004, China.
Environ Pollut. 2024 Nov 15;361:124899. doi: 10.1016/j.envpol.2024.124899. Epub 2024 Sep 6.
off fireworks during the Spring Festival (SF) is a traditional practice in China. However, because of its environmental impact, the Chinese government has banned this practice completely. Existing evaluations of the effectiveness of firework prohibition policies (FPPs) lack spatiotemporal perspectives, making it difficult to comprehensively assess their effects on air quality. Consequently, this study used remote sensing technology based on aerosol optical depth and multiple variables, compared nine statistical learning methods, and selected the optimal model, transformer, to estimate daily spatiotemporal continuous PM concentration datasets for Tianjin from 2016 to 2020. The overall model accuracy reached a root mean square error of 15.30 μg/m³, a mean absolute error of 9.55 μg/m³, a mean absolute percentage error of 21.07%, and an R of 0.88. Subsequently, we analysed the variations in PM concentrations from three time dimensions-the entire year, winter, and SF periods-to exclude the impact of interannual variations on the experimental results. Additionally, we quantitatively estimated firework-specific PM concentrations based on time-series forecasting. The results showed that during the three years following the implementation of the FPPs, firework-specific PM concentrations decreased by 52.70%, 49.76%, and 86.90%, respectively, compared to the year before the implementation of the FPPs. Spatially, the central urban area and industrial zones are more affected by FPPs than the suburbs. However, daily variations of PM concentrations during the SF showed that high concentrations of PM produced in a short period will return to normal rapidly and will not cause lasting effects. Therefore, the management of fireworks needs to consider both environmental protection and the public's emotional attachment to traditional customs, rather than simply imposing a blanket ban on fireworks. We advocate improving firework policies in four aspects-production, sales, supervision, and control-to promote sustainable development of the ecological environment and human society.
春节期间(SF)燃放烟花在中国是一种传统习俗。然而,由于其对环境的影响,中国政府已全面禁止这一习俗。现有对烟花禁放政策(FPPs)有效性的评估缺乏时空视角,难以全面评估其对空气质量的影响。因此,本研究使用基于气溶胶光学深度和多个变量的遥感技术,比较了九种统计学习方法,并选择了最优模型——变压器,以估计 2016 年至 2020 年天津市逐日时空连续 PM 浓度数据集。总体模型精度达到 15.30μg/m³ 的均方根误差、9.55μg/m³ 的平均绝对误差、21.07%的平均绝对百分比误差和 0.88 的 R 值。随后,我们从全年、冬季和 SF 期三个时间维度分析了 PM 浓度的变化,以排除年际变化对实验结果的影响。此外,我们还根据时间序列预测定量估计了烟花特有的 PM 浓度。结果表明,在实施 FPPs 的三年中,与实施 FPPs 前一年相比,烟花特有的 PM 浓度分别下降了 52.70%、49.76%和 86.90%。从空间上看,中心城区和工业区比郊区受 FPPs 的影响更大。然而,SF 期间 PM 浓度的日变化表明,短时间内产生的高浓度 PM 会迅速恢复正常,不会造成持久影响。因此,烟花管理需要考虑环境保护和公众对传统习俗的情感依恋,而不是简单地全面禁止烟花。我们主张从生产、销售、监管和控制四个方面改进烟花政策,以促进生态环境和人类社会的可持续发展。