Beder Dilara, Pelowski Matthew, Imamoğlu Çağrı
Bilkent University, Turkey.
University of Vienna, Austria.
J Eye Mov Res. 2024 Aug 9;17(2). doi: 10.16910/jemr.17.2.4. eCollection 2024.
Buildings are an integral part of our physical environment and have aesthetic significance with respect to the organizational integrity of architectural elements. While Gestalt principles are essential in design education, their relationship with architectural features remains understudied. The present study explored how Gestalt principles and complexity levels influence evaluations of building façades through the use of questionnaires and eye tracking. Twenty-four two-dimensional black and white façade drawings, manipulated using selected Gestalt principles (similarity and proximity) to achieve different levels of complexity (low, medium & high), were presented to 79 participants. The results suggested a negative linear relationship between aesthetic ratings and complexity levels across selected Gestalt principles. In addition, as expected, participants had the highest number of fixations, shortest fixation durations, and lowest aesthetic ratings for higher levels of complexity. Results involving Gestalt principles revealed that proximity-based designs received higher aesthetic ratings, demanded less time, elicited lower number of fixations, and resulted in shorter fixation durations. Conversely, similarity-based designs received lower aesthetic ratings, demanded more time, elicited higher number of fixations, and resulted in longer fixation durations. These findings offer insights into architectural aesthetic experiences and inform future research directions.
建筑是我们物质环境中不可或缺的一部分,并且就建筑元素的组织完整性而言具有美学意义。虽然格式塔原则在设计教育中至关重要,但其与建筑特征之间的关系仍未得到充分研究。本研究通过问卷调查和眼动追踪,探讨了格式塔原则和复杂程度如何影响对建筑立面的评价。向79名参与者展示了24幅二维黑白立面图,这些图运用选定的格式塔原则(相似性和接近性)进行处理,以实现不同程度的复杂性(低、中、高)。结果表明,在选定的格式塔原则中,美学评分与复杂程度之间存在负线性关系。此外,正如预期的那样,对于较高的复杂程度,参与者的注视次数最多、注视持续时间最短且美学评分最低。涉及格式塔原则的结果显示,基于接近性的设计获得了更高的美学评分,所需时间更少,引发的注视次数更少,且注视持续时间更短。相反,基于相似性的设计获得的美学评分较低,所需时间更多,引发的注视次数更多,且注视持续时间更长。这些发现为建筑美学体验提供了见解,并为未来的研究方向提供了参考。