Office of Clinical Performance and Health Impact, Indian Health Service Headquarters, Rockville, MD, USA.
Department of Emergency Medicine, University of Arizona College of Medicine Phoenix, Phoenix, AZ, USA.
Wilderness Environ Med. 2024 Dec;35(4):443-449. doi: 10.1177/10806032241278982. Epub 2024 Sep 12.
Facilities in austere environments may consider emergency care beyond their scope. Often patients with high-acuity conditions have no other choice than to present to these facilities. The disconnect between the intent of health systems planners and the reality faced by providers manifests as facilities unable to manage such cases.The Indian Health Service, with a range of stakeholders, developed an emergency care delivery assessment tool for facilities in austere environments, designed to identify deficiencies in facility readiness for emergency care delivery across four areas: 1. Procedural2. Human resources3. Non-pharmacologic material resources4. Pharmacologic material resources.
The tool's underlying architecture is a resource matrix similar to hospital-based tools, using the "Facility" component of the WHO Emergency Care Systems Framework as the Y-axis and undifferentiated presentations taught by the WHO basic emergency care course, advanced trauma life support, and advanced life support in obstetrics as the X-axis. The tool was piloted at a remote frontier clinic.
We found 48 deficiencies: 7 procedural, 1 human resources, 31 non-pharmacologic materials, and 9 pharmacologic materials. We aggregated deficiencies by facility function to assess the capacity to perform each. We also aggregated deficiencies by clinical presentation to identify targets for educational interventions.
We successfully created a novel emergency care capacity assessment tool for use in austere environments using materials with broad international consensus. The successful pilot found deficiencies across all 4 areas. This tool may be useful in many other remote domestic facilities and rural health posts in low- and middle-income countries.
在艰苦环境下的医疗设施可能会考虑提供超出其能力范围的紧急医疗服务。通常情况下,患有高度危急病症的患者除了前往这些设施就诊外别无选择。卫生系统规划者的意图与提供者面临的现实之间的脱节表现为,这些设施无法处理此类病例。美国印第安人服务局与一系列利益相关者合作,为艰苦环境下的医疗设施开发了一种紧急医疗服务交付评估工具,旨在识别四个领域的紧急医疗服务准备方面的缺陷:1. 程序;2. 人力资源;3. 非药物资源;4. 药物资源。
该工具的基础架构是类似于医院使用的资源矩阵,使用世界卫生组织紧急医疗系统框架中的“设施”部分作为 Y 轴,以及世界卫生组织基本急救课程、高级创伤生命支持和妇产科高级生命支持所教授的未分化的表现作为 X 轴。该工具在一个偏远的边境诊所进行了试点。
我们发现了 48 个缺陷:7 个程序,1 个人力资源,31 个非药物资源和 9 个药物资源。我们按设施功能对缺陷进行了分类,以评估执行每个功能的能力。我们还按临床表现对缺陷进行了分类,以确定教育干预的目标。
我们成功地使用具有广泛国际共识的材料,为艰苦环境下的紧急医疗服务创建了一种新颖的能力评估工具。成功的试点发现了所有四个领域的缺陷。该工具可能在许多其他偏远的国内设施和中低收入国家的农村卫生所中有用。