Odonkor Michelle N, Pahwa Bhavya, Rincon-Torroella Jordina, Abu-Bonsrah Nancy, Yenokyan Gayane, Dada Olaoluwa Ezekiel, Goodwin C Rory, Huang Judy, Groves Mari L
Department of Neurosurgery, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland, USA.
Medical School, University College of Medical Sciences, Delhi, India.
World Neurosurg. 2025 Jan;193:492-510. doi: 10.1016/j.wneu.2024.09.016. Epub 2024 Sep 10.
The current neurosurgical workforce is not large enough to address the significant burden of neurosurgical disease worldwide, and women are under-represented in this surgical specialty. However, trainee opportunities are particularly scarce in lower- and middle-income countries, where the burden of neurosurgical disease is high. Thus, the primary aim of this study was to assess the effects of gender and country on perceived access to neurosurgical research and mentorship opportunities.
A cross-sectional survey evaluating perceived access to neurosurgical research and mentorship opportunities was distributed electronically to medical students and unspecialized residents in 10 countries (Colombia, India, Ghana, Nigeria, Saudi Arabia, Spain, Uganda, the United Kingdom, the United States, and Venezuela).
34.0% of men versus 24.9% of women reported interest in neurosurgery (P < 0.001). Only 16.1% of trainees reported adequate access to neurosurgical research opportunities, which did not vary by gender overall (P = 0.070). However, more women reported inadequate access in the United States (P = 0.038), and more men reported inadequate access in Colombia (P = 0.043). In Colombia (P < 0.001), Nigeria (P = 0.003), Saudi Arabia (P = 0.038), the United States (P = 0.004), and Venezuela (P < 0.001), a lower proportion of women than men reported ever having a neurosurgery mentor of their same gender. 59.0% of female respondents noted that having access to female neurosurgeon mentors would increase their interest in neurosurgery, compared to 28.5% of male respondents (P < 0.001).
More male than female medical trainees in the surveyed countries reported interest in neurosurgery. However, access to adequate neurosurgical research opportunities, although relatively low overall, did not vary by gender in most countries. Access to gender-concordant mentorship was less common for women than for men, but women expressed that enhanced access to female neurosurgeon mentors would increase their interest in the field. These findings suggest potential avenues for intervention to augment and diversify the global neurosurgical workforce.
目前神经外科领域的专业人员数量不足以应对全球神经外科疾病的沉重负担,而且女性在这一外科专业中的占比过低。然而,在神经外科疾病负担较重的低收入和中等收入国家,实习机会尤其稀缺。因此,本研究的主要目的是评估性别和国家对获得神经外科研究及导师指导机会的认知的影响。
一项关于获得神经外科研究及导师指导机会的认知的横断面调查,通过电子方式分发给10个国家(哥伦比亚、印度、加纳、尼日利亚、沙特阿拉伯、西班牙、乌干达、英国、美国和委内瑞拉)的医学生和未专科化的住院医师。
报告对神经外科感兴趣的男性占34.0%,而女性占24.9%(P<0.001)。只有16.1%的实习生表示有足够的神经外科研究机会,总体上这在性别上没有差异(P=0.070)。然而,在美国,更多女性报告获得机会不足(P=0.038),而在哥伦比亚,更多男性报告获得机会不足(P=0.043)。在哥伦比亚(P<0.001)、尼日利亚(P=0.003)、沙特阿拉伯(P=0.038)、美国(P=0.004)和委内瑞拉(P<0.001),报告曾有同性别神经外科导师的女性比例低于男性。59.0%的女性受访者指出,有女性神经外科导师会增加她们对神经外科的兴趣,而男性受访者中这一比例为28.5%(P<0.001)。
在接受调查的国家中,对神经外科感兴趣的医学实习生男性多于女性。然而,获得充足的神经外科研究机会,尽管总体上相对较少,但在大多数国家在性别上没有差异。女性获得性别匹配的导师指导的情况比男性少见,但女性表示,增加获得女性神经外科导师的机会会提高她们对该领域的兴趣。这些发现提示了可能的干预途径,以增加和使全球神经外科专业人员队伍多样化。