Alwakaa Omar, Enriquez-Marulanda Alejandro, Ramirez-Velandia Felipe, Filo Jean, Mensah Emmanuel, Wadhwa Aryan, Fodor Thomas B, Pettersson Samuel D, McNeil Evan Paul, Young Michael, Muram Sandeep, See Alfred P, Granstein Justin H, Taussky Philipp, Ogilvy Christopher S
Neurosurgical Service, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts, USA.
Neurosurgical Service, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts, USA.
World Neurosurg. 2024 Nov;191:e697-e706. doi: 10.1016/j.wneu.2024.09.026. Epub 2024 Sep 10.
The Matsushima grade has traditionally been used to evaluate vessel ingrowth from the superficial temporal artery after encephalo-duro-arterio-synangiosis (EDAS) for Moyamoya disease (MMD) patients. However, this grading is subjective and prone to measurement variability. Herein, we propose the orbital grading system quantifying leptomeningeal and burr hole-related vessel-ingrowth from the superficial temporal artery and/or middle meningeal artery to the middle and anterior cerebral arteries post EDAS in MMD patients.
An anatomical classification was developed by reference to 2 parallel vertical lines from the bony landmarks of the orbit, categorized from Grade 0-3. Regression models were used to compare clinical and functional outcomes of our grading system with the Matsushima scale.
Forty MMD patients, with median age of 48 years, mostly females (72.5%), underwent 56 EDAS procedures. Presentation included ischemic events (65.0%), hemorrhage (22.5%), and seizures (7.5%). Most patients were categorized as Suzuki ≥ IV (69.5%). Fifty EDAS (89.9%) had concurrent burr holes placed (parietal and frontal regions). At a median follow-up of 13.7 months, collateral growth was graded as follows: grade 0 (6; 10.8%), grade 1 (12; 21.4%), grade 2 (23; 41.1%), and grade 3 (15; 26.8%). Linear regression showed similarities in the distribution between the orbital grading system and Matsushima grading (r = 0.86; P < 0.01). Ischemic events were fewer in hemispheres categorized as grade 2-3 compared to grade 0-1 (P = 0.047) as well as in Matsushima grading A or B compared to C (P = 0.047).
The orbital grading system demonstrated agreement in identifying postoperative ischemic events as the Matsushima grade and provides a more practical and objective evaluation of collateral vessel ingrowth after EDAS with and without burr holes.
传统上,松岛分级用于评估烟雾病(MMD)患者行脑-硬脑膜-动脉-血管吻合术(EDAS)后颞浅动脉的血管长入情况。然而,这种分级是主观的,且容易出现测量差异。在此,我们提出眼眶分级系统,用于量化MMD患者EDAS术后软脑膜及与骨孔相关的颞浅动脉和/或脑膜中动脉向大脑中动脉和大脑前动脉的血管长入情况。
通过参照眼眶骨性标志的两条平行垂直线制定解剖学分类,分为0-3级。使用回归模型比较我们的分级系统与松岛分级的临床和功能结果。
40例MMD患者,中位年龄48岁,多数为女性(72.5%),接受了56次EDAS手术。临床表现包括缺血性事件(65.0%)、出血(22.5%)和癫痫发作(7.5%)。大多数患者被归类为铃木分级≥IV级(69.5%)。50例EDAS手术(89.9%)同时进行了骨孔置入(顶叶和额叶区域)。中位随访13.7个月时,侧支血管生长分级如下:0级(6例;10.8%),1级(12例;21.4%),2级(23例;41.1%),3级(15例;26.8%)。线性回归显示眼眶分级系统和松岛分级之间的分布相似(r = 0.86;P < 0.01)。与0-1级相比,2-3级半球的缺血性事件较少(P = 0.047),与松岛分级C级相比,A或B级的缺血性事件也较少(P = 0.047)。
眼眶分级系统在识别术后缺血性事件方面与松岛分级具有一致性,并为有无骨孔的EDAS术后侧支血管长入提供了更实用、客观的评估。