School of Nursing, University of Victoria, 3800 Finnerty Road, Victoria, BC V8P 5C2, Canada; Institute on Aging & Lifelong Health, University of Victoria, 3800 Finnerty Road, Victoria, BC V8P 5C2, Canada.
School of Nursing, Camosun College, 4461 Interurban Rd, Victoria, BC V9E 2C1, Canada.
Nurse Educ Pract. 2024 Oct;80:104134. doi: 10.1016/j.nepr.2024.104134. Epub 2024 Sep 11.
AIM /OBJECTIVE: To identify strategies nursing students recommend for responding to discrimination in their program.
The nursing discipline is rooted in social justice, which is increasingly positioned as practices that seek to enhance equity in health and healthcare. Yet, a growing body of knowledge indicates nursing students experience discrimination by virtue of race, sexual identity, gender identity, ability and mental health in nursing programs. There is a dearth of information that speaks to redressing discrimination in nursing schools, particularly from the perspectives of nursing students.
This study reports on the findings of the qualitative portion of a mixed-methods project.
Data were collected via qualitative interviews (n=20) conducted on the Zoom platform. Inclusion criteria included any nursing graduate or undergraduate student enrolled in two institutions in Western Canada. Analysis was guided by a combination of thematic analysis with interpretive description to facilitate the identification of broader themes within the context of relevant disciplinary considerations.
Three key themes that represent nursing student perspectives to redress discrimination in their programs were identified: (1) strategies to redress discrimination at the level of the educator/curriculum, (2) strategies to redress discrimination at the structural level and, (3) strategies to support students who have experienced discrimination.
Systematic curriculum updates and educator supports to ensure up-to date knowledge and appropriate educator approaches are needed in classroom and clinical settings. The integration of equity-seeking processes at higher levels, e.g. for example, nursing standards of practice, was identified as essential to redress discrimination in education as well in everyday nursing practice. Lastly, a clearly defined reporting pathway was suggested to support students who have been subject to discrimination. Given this is one of the first investigations into student perspectives on redressing discrimination in nursing schools, additional research is needed to evoke meaningful change.
目的/目标:确定护理专业学生应对专业课程中歧视的建议策略。
护理学科根植于社会正义,其被定位为寻求增强健康和医疗保健公平性的实践。然而,越来越多的知识表明,护理专业的学生因种族、性取向、性别认同、能力和心理健康等因素而在护理课程中遭受歧视。几乎没有信息涉及在护理学校纠正歧视问题,尤其是从护理学生的角度来看。
本研究报告了混合方法项目定性部分的结果。
通过在 Zoom 平台上进行的定性访谈(n=20)收集数据。纳入标准包括在加拿大西部的两所机构就读的任何护理专业的毕业生或本科生。分析遵循主题分析与解释性描述的结合,以在相关学科考虑的背景下识别更广泛的主题。
确定了三个代表护理学生观点的关键主题,以纠正他们专业课程中的歧视:(1)在教育者/课程层面纠正歧视的策略,(2)在结构层面纠正歧视的策略,以及(3)支持遭受歧视的学生的策略。
需要在课堂和临床环境中进行系统的课程更新和教育者支持,以确保教育者具备最新知识和适当的方法。在更高层次上整合公平寻求过程,例如护理实践标准,被确定为纠正教育中以及日常护理实践中的歧视的必要条件。最后,建议建立一个明确的报告途径,以支持遭受歧视的学生。鉴于这是首次对护理学校学生纠正歧视的观点进行调查,需要进一步研究以引发有意义的变革。