Yu Hang, Tang Bin, Fu Yuchuan, Wei Weige, He Yisong, Dai Guyu, Xiao Qing
Department of Radiotherapy Physics & Technology, West China Hospital, Sichuan University, Chengdu 610041, Sichuan Province, PR China.
Department of Radiation Oncology, Radiation Oncology Key Laboratory Of Sichuan Province, Sichuan Cancer Hospital& Institute, Chengdu, Sichuan, China.
Eur J Radiol. 2024 Dec;181:111735. doi: 10.1016/j.ejrad.2024.111735. Epub 2024 Sep 14.
This study aimed to quantitatively evaluate the inter-platform reproducibility and longitudinal acquisition repeatability of MRI radiomics features in Fluid-Attenuated Inversion Recovery (FLAIR), T2-weighted (T2W), and T1-weighted (T1W) sequences on MR-Linac systems using an American College of Radiology (ACR) phantom.
This study used two MR-Linac systems (A and B) in different cancer centers. The ACR phantom was scanned on system A daily for 30 consecutive days to evaluate longitudinal repeatability. Additionally, retest data were collected after repositioning the phantom. Inter-platform reproducibility was assessed by conducting scans under identical conditions using system B. Regions of interest were delineated on the T1W sequence from system A and mapped to other sequences via rigid registration. Intra-observer and inter-observer comparisons were conducted. Repeatability and reproducibility were assessed using the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) and coefficient of variation (CV). Robust radiomics features were identified based on ICC>0.9 and CV<10 %.
Analysis showed that a higher proportion of radiomics features derived from longitudinal FLAIR sequence (51.65 %) met robustness criteria compared to T2W (48.35 %) and T1W (43.96 %). Additionally, more inter-platform features from the FLAIR sequence (62.64 %) were robust compared to T2W (42.86 %) and T1W (39.56 %). Test-retest and intra-observer repeatability were excellent across all sequences, with a median ICC of 0.99 and CV<5%. However, inter-observer reproducibility was inferior, especially for the T1W sequence.
Different sequences show variations in repeatability and reproducibility. The FLAIR sequence demonstrated advantages in both longitudinal repeatability and inter-platform reproducibility. Caution is warranted when interpreting data, particularly in longitudinal or multiplatform radiomics studies.
本研究旨在使用美国放射学会(ACR)体模,定量评估MR直线加速器系统上液体衰减反转恢复(FLAIR)、T2加权(T2W)和T1加权(T1W)序列中MRI影像组学特征的平台间可重复性和纵向采集重复性。
本研究使用了不同癌症中心的两台MR直线加速器系统(A和B)。ACR体模在系统A上连续30天每日进行扫描,以评估纵向重复性。此外,在重新定位体模后收集复测数据。通过使用系统B在相同条件下进行扫描来评估平台间可重复性。在系统A的T1W序列上勾画感兴趣区域,并通过刚性配准映射到其他序列。进行了观察者内和观察者间比较。使用组内相关系数(ICC)和变异系数(CV)评估重复性和可重复性。基于ICC>0.9和CV<10%确定稳健的影像组学特征。
分析表明,与T2W(48.35%)和T1W(43.96%)相比,源自纵向FLAIR序列的影像组学特征中符合稳健性标准的比例更高(51.65%)。此外,与T2W(42.86%)和T1W(39.56%)相比,FLAIR序列的更多平台间特征是稳健的。所有序列的重测和观察者内重复性都非常好,中位ICC为0.99且CV<5%。然而,观察者间可重复性较差,尤其是对于T1W序列。
不同序列在重复性和可重复性方面存在差异。FLAIR序列在纵向重复性和平台间可重复性方面均显示出优势。在解释数据时应谨慎,尤其是在纵向或多平台影像组学研究中。