Varghese Sunil Sam, Kumar Navneet, Varghese Ashish
Department of ENT, Chrisitan Medical College, Ludhiana, Punjab, India.
Department of ENT, Bangalore Baptist Hospital, Bengaluru, Karnataka, India.
J Voice. 2024 Sep 16. doi: 10.1016/j.jvoice.2024.08.033.
Poor glottic exposure in microlaryngeal surgery can result in difficult instrumentation or incomplete surgery affecting surgical outcomes. Anticipating poor glottic exposure preoperatively allows surgeons to prepare adequately, ensuring successful surgery. This study aims to determine the diagnostic utility of 4-mm zero-degree rigid endoscopic laryngeal examination as a tool to predict glottic exposure in microlaryngoscopy (MLS).
Cross-sectional observational study.
This is a cross-sectional study, conducted from March 1, 2022 to November 30, 2023 at the ENT department of a tertiary care hospital in North India. A total of 35 adult participants who underwent MLS were consecutively enrolled. Participants in whom the lesion was obscuring the anterior commissure and in whom gag reflex prevented complete zero-degree laryngeal examination were excluded from the study. All enrolled participants were evaluated preoperatively with a 4-mm rigid zero-degree laryngoscopic examination and the Laryngoscore. The total score on the Laryngoscore proforma was calculated and recorded. The visualized glottis on zero-degree laryngoscopy was graded as follows: grade 1, anterior commissure and the entire glottic plane can be seen; grade 2, glottis can be seen but not the anterior commissure; grade 3, only the posterior half of the glottis can be seen; grade 4, only the arytenoids can be seen. The glottic exposure on MLS was also assessed using the same grading system. Depending on the exposure of the anterior commissure, the cohort was divided into two groups: good laryngeal exposure and difficult laryngeal exposure. Receiver operating characteristic curve analysis was done to evaluate the predictive accuracy of zero-degree laryngoscopy and to compare it with Laryngoscore.
A total of 35 adults participated in the study, of which 28 were men (80%) with a median (range) age of 45 (24-76) years. The area under the curve for zero-degree laryngoscopy and Laryngoscore were 0.97 and 0.83, respectively. The optimal cut-off value (sensitivity, specificity) to identify difficult laryngeal exposure for zero-degree laryngoscopy and Laryngoscore were 1.5 (93.3%, 100%) and 4.5 (80%, 85%), respectively.
Zero-degree laryngoscopy is an excellent predictor of glottic exposure on MLS. Its accuracy surpasses that of the Laryngoscore in identifying an ideal candidate for MLS.
显微喉镜手术中声门暴露不佳可导致器械操作困难或手术不彻底,影响手术效果。术前预测声门暴露不佳可使外科医生充分准备,确保手术成功。本研究旨在确定4毫米零度硬质内镜喉镜检查作为预测显微喉镜检查(MLS)中声门暴露工具的诊断效用。
横断面观察性研究。
这是一项横断面研究,于2022年3月1日至2023年11月30日在印度北部一家三级护理医院的耳鼻喉科进行。共有35名接受MLS的成年参与者连续入组。病变遮挡前联合以及咽反射妨碍完整的零度喉镜检查的参与者被排除在研究之外。所有入组参与者术前均接受4毫米硬质零度喉镜检查和喉镜评分评估。计算并记录喉镜评分表格的总分。零度喉镜检查时可视化的声门分级如下:1级,可见前联合和整个声门平面;2级,可见声门但不见前联合;3级,仅可见声门后半部分;4级,仅可见杓状软骨。MLS时的声门暴露也使用相同的分级系统进行评估。根据前联合的暴露情况,将队列分为两组:良好的喉部暴露和困难的喉部暴露。进行受试者操作特征曲线分析以评估零度喉镜检查的预测准确性,并将其与喉镜评分进行比较。
共有35名成年人参与研究,其中28名男性(80%),中位(范围)年龄为45(24 - 76)岁。零度喉镜检查和喉镜评分的曲线下面积分别为0.97和0.83。用于识别零度喉镜检查和喉镜评分困难喉部暴露的最佳截断值(敏感性、特异性)分别为1.5(93.3%,100%)和4.5(80%,85%)。
零度喉镜检查是MLS中声门暴露的优秀预测指标。在识别MLS的理想候选者方面,其准确性超过喉镜评分。