Institute of Health Policy, Management, and Evaluation, Dalla Lana School of Public Health, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Temerty Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2024 Sep 17;24(1):1080. doi: 10.1186/s12913-024-11503-0.
People experiencing homelessness have increased prevalence, morbidity, and mortality of cardiovascular disease (CVD), attributable to several traditional and non-traditional risk factors. While this burden is well-known, mainstream CVD management plans and healthcare delivery have not been developed with people experiencing homelessness in mind nor tailored to their unique context. The overall objective of this work was to explore and synthesize what is known about CVD management experiences, programs, interventions, and/or recommendations specifically for people experiencing homelessness.
We conducted a scoping review to combine qualitative and quantitative studies in a single review using the Arksey and O'Malley framework and lived experience participation. We performed a comprehensive search of OVID Medline, Embase, PsychINFO, CINAHL, Web of Science, Social Sciences Index, Cochrane, and the grey literature with key search terms for homelessness, cardiovascular disease, and programs. All dates, geographic locations, and study designs were included. Articles were analyzed using conventional content analysis.
We included 37 articles in this review. Most of the work was done in the USA. We synthesized articles' findings into 1) barriers/challenges faced by people experiencing homelessness and their providers with CVD management and care delivery (competing priorities, lifestyle challenges, medication adherence, access to care, and discrimination), 2) seven international programs/interventions that have been developed for people experiencing homelessness and CVD management with learnings, and 3) practical recommendations and possible solutions at the patient encounter level (relationships, appointment priorities, lifestyle, medication), clinic organization level (scheduling, location, equipment, and multi-disciplinary partnership), and systems level (root cause of homelessness, and cultural safety).
There is no 'one-size-fits all' approach to CVD management for people experiencing homelessness, and it is met with complexity, diversity, and intersectionality based on various contexts. It is clear, however, we need to move to more practically-implemented, community-driven solutions with lived experience and community partnership at the core. Future work includes tackling the root cause of homelessness with affordable housing, exploring ways to bring cardiac specialist care to the community, and investigating the role of digital technology as an avenue for CVD management in the homeless community. We hope this review is valuable in providing knowledge gaps and future direction for health care providers, health services research teams, and community organizations.
无家可归者的心血管疾病(CVD)患病率、发病率和死亡率有所增加,这归因于一些传统和非传统的风险因素。尽管这种负担是众所周知的,但主流的 CVD 管理计划和医疗保健服务的提供并没有考虑到无家可归者的需求,也没有针对他们的独特情况进行调整。这项工作的总体目标是探索和综合了解专门针对无家可归者的 CVD 管理经验、计划、干预措施和/或建议。
我们采用 Arksey 和 O'Malley 框架以及生活体验参与,对定性和定量研究进行了综合审查。我们使用了 OVID Medline、Embase、PsychINFO、CINAHL、Web of Science、社会科学索引、Cochrane 和灰色文献中的关键搜索词,对无家可归、心血管疾病和方案进行了全面搜索。所有日期、地理位置和研究设计均包括在内。文章采用常规内容分析进行分析。
我们在本次综述中纳入了 37 篇文章。其中大部分工作在美国进行。我们将文章的发现综合为 1)无家可归者及其 CVD 管理和护理提供者面临的障碍/挑战(优先事项竞争、生活方式挑战、药物依从性、获得医疗保健的机会和歧视),2)针对无家可归者和 CVD 管理而制定的七个国际计划/干预措施及其经验教训,3)在患者接触层面(人际关系、预约重点、生活方式、药物)、诊所组织层面(日程安排、地点、设备和多学科合作)和系统层面(无家可归的根本原因和文化安全)的实际建议和可能的解决方案。
对于无家可归者的 CVD 管理,没有“一刀切”的方法,并且由于各种情况的复杂性、多样性和交叉性,它是复杂的。然而,显然我们需要采取更实用的、以社区为驱动的解决方案,以生活体验和社区伙伴关系为核心。未来的工作包括解决可负担住房的无家可归根本原因、探索将心脏专家护理带入社区的方法以及研究数字技术作为无家可归社区 CVD 管理的途径。我们希望本综述能为医疗保健提供者、卫生服务研究团队和社区组织提供知识空白和未来方向。