Policy Research, Economics and Analytics Unit, Health Policy Branch, Health Canada / Government of Canada, 70 Colombine Driveway, Ottawa, Ontario, K1A 0K9, Canada,
J Ment Health Policy Econ. 2024 Sep 1;27(3):75-84.
Mental ill-health-illness or conditions related to mental health, including dementia, schizophrenia, mood (affective) disorders, and mental and behaviour disorders due to psychoactive substance and alcohol use - places a significant burden on society in terms of economic, health, and social costs. Focusing on direct health care costs, estimated expenditures on treating mental health conditions accounted for up to 14% of total health expenditures across 12 OECD countries over the period of 2003 to 2010.
The purpose of this study was to estimate the direct health care costs associated with the treatment of mental ill-health in Canada for the year 2019 using currently available guidelines. A consistent and systematic method, such as that used in the OECD guidelines on expenditure by disease, age and gender under the System of Health Accounts, can provide valuable information for policy makers and improve comparability of Canadian estimates with those of peer countries.
To derive comprehensive, and internationally comparable estimates of mental health care expenditures, the results were classified according to the OECD System of Health Accounts 2011 for the following cost components: hospitals, physicians, psychologists in private practice, prescription drugs, and community mental health care. Based on data availability, both public and private expenditures were captured. Where data were lacking, estimates were based on the published literature.
Total expenditure for mental health care was estimated at $17.1 billion in Canada in 2019. Hospital services (inpatient and outpatient) represent the largest component totaling $5.5 billion or 32% of total mental health spending. They are followed by expenditures on prescribed pharmaceutical drugs of $4.3 billion (25%), community-based care of $3.6 billion (21%), physician services of $2.7 billion (16%) and services of psychologists in private practice of $1.1 billion (6%).
The study provided the most recent and comprehensive estimate of mental health expenditure in Canada. The results for similar cost components, are comparable to those found in the previous studies. Expenditures directed towards mental health treatment accounted for 6.4% of total health expenditures, and 6.9% of public health expenditures, in 2019, on par with the OECD average of 6.7% for twenty-three countries. Among considered cost components, community-based mental health and addiction services remain an area where further work is needed the most, including a standardized list of services reported by each Canadian province/territory regardless of care setting, service administrator or funder. In Canada, data challenges are considerable to assess private spending out-of-pocket or through third-party insurance for services by psychologists or psychotherapists, as well as residential and home care. Given data challenges, the total expenditure estimate is likely conservative. IMPLICATIONS: Consistent and comparable estimates such as these can be used to better understand how resources are being used in the treatment of mental health, including key cost drivers, and the impact of policy changes, as well as to undertake reliable inter-jurisdictional and international comparisons.
精神健康问题-包括痴呆、精神分裂症、情绪(情感)障碍以及精神活性物质和酒精使用导致的心理和行为障碍等心理健康相关疾病,给社会带来了巨大的经济、健康和社会成本负担。仅关注直接的医疗保健成本,在 2003 年至 2010 年期间,12 个经合组织国家中,用于治疗精神健康状况的支出估计占总卫生支出的 14%。
本研究旨在使用当前可用的指南,估算 2019 年加拿大精神健康问题治疗的直接医疗保健费用。经合组织疾病支出、年龄和性别分类指南中采用的一致和系统的方法,如卫生账户体系中的方法,可以为决策者提供有价值的信息,并提高加拿大与同行国家估计值的可比性。
为了获得全面且具有国际可比性的精神卫生保健支出估计值,结果根据经合组织 2011 年卫生账户体系进行了分类,包括以下成本构成部分:医院、医生、私人执业的心理学家、处方药物和社区精神卫生保健。根据数据可用性,同时包括了公共和私人支出。在缺乏数据的情况下,根据已发表的文献进行了估计。
2019 年,加拿大的精神卫生保健总支出估计为 171 亿美元。医院服务(住院和门诊)占比最大,总计 55 亿美元,占精神卫生总支出的 32%。其次是处方药支出 43 亿美元(25%)、社区精神卫生保健支出 36 亿美元(21%)、医生服务支出 27 亿美元(16%)和私人执业心理学家服务支出 11 亿美元(6%)。
本研究提供了加拿大最新和最全面的精神卫生支出估计值。类似成本构成部分的结果与之前的研究结果相当。2019 年,精神卫生治疗支出占总卫生支出的 6.4%,占公共卫生支出的 6.9%,与经合组织 23 个国家的平均水平 6.7%相当。在所考虑的成本构成部分中,社区精神卫生和成瘾服务仍然是最需要进一步工作的领域,包括每个加拿大省/地区无论护理地点、服务管理员或资金来源,都要报告标准化的服务清单。在加拿大,评估心理学家或心理治疗师服务、住院和家庭护理的私人自付或第三方保险的私人支出存在相当大的数据挑战。鉴于数据挑战,总支出估计可能较为保守。
此类一致和可比的估计可以用于更好地了解资源在精神健康治疗中的使用情况,包括关键成本驱动因素,以及政策变化的影响,并进行可靠的司法管辖区间和国际比较。