Lengacher Cecile A, Reich Richard R, Rodriguez Carmen S, Nguyen Anh Thy, Park Jong Y, Meng Hongdao, Tinsley Sara, Hueluer Gizem, Donovan Kristine A, Moscoso Manolete S, Bornstein Elizabeth, Kiluk John, Nidamanur Sreenidhi, Padgett Lynne S, Lucas Jean M, Fonseca Tamela, Joshi Anisha, Lin Katherine J, Goodman Matthew, Kip Kevin E
University of South Florida College of Nursing, Tampa, Florida, USA.
Moffitt Cancer Center, Tampa, Florida, USA.
J Integr Complement Med. 2025 Jan;31(1):75-91. doi: 10.1089/jicm.2024.0184. Epub 2024 Sep 18.
The Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) Program for breast cancer survivors (BCS) is designed to enhance cognitive training through formal and informal meditational practices. This randomized clinical trial (RCT) aimed to evaluate if BCS assigned to either the MBSR(BC), Breast Cancer Education Support (BCES), or Usual Care (UC) regimens experienced greater improvements at 6, 12, and 26 weeks on objective and subjective cognitive performance. BCS ( = 212) randomized to a three-group RCT: MBSR(BC) ( = 91), BCES ( = 90), or UC ( = 31) were assessed on cognitive performance and symptoms at baseline, 6, 12, and 26 weeks. Linear mixed models were fit to evaluate the effects of the MBSR(BC) program, hypothesizing ordered effect improvements: (MBSR[BC] highest, BCES intermediate, UC lowest) along with baseline characteristics evaluated as moderators. Of the BCS (mean age of 57), 73% were White, and non-Hispanic, and 77% received both chemotherapy (CT) and radiation. Cognitive performance improved in all groups. Although there were no statistically significant between-group differences in cognitive outcomes, significant symptom reductions occurred for the MBSR(BC) group ( = 0.003). Within-group effect size analysis at 26 weeks showed substantial improvements in all three groups (effect sizes >0.50) in subjective impairments and quality of life (effect size >0.50) and objective measures of cognitive performance. MBSR(BC) showed the largest within-group effect size in the reduction of fatigue (effect size = 0.81). Effect sizes occurred in the hypothesized direction for 10 of the 18 outcomes. Although the MBSR(BC) program did not show significant differences in cognitive performance compared with BCES and UC, all groups improved and reductions in fatigue were beneficial for MBSR(BC). Results suggest that cognitive performance may improve after CT over time considering one's natural history. Furthermore, BCS enrolled in RCTs may be more motivated to improve their health status (NCT02786797).
针对乳腺癌幸存者(BCS)的基于正念减压(MBSR)计划旨在通过正式和非正式的冥想练习来加强认知训练。这项随机临床试验(RCT)旨在评估被分配到MBSR(BC)、乳腺癌教育支持(BCES)或常规护理(UC)方案的BCS在6周、12周和26周时在客观和主观认知表现上是否有更大改善。212名BCS被随机分配到三组RCT中:MBSR(BC)组(n = 91)、BCES组(n = 90)或UC组(n = 31),并在基线、6周、12周和26周时对其认知表现和症状进行评估。采用线性混合模型来评估MBSR(BC)计划的效果,假设效果呈有序改善:(MBSR[BC]最高,BCES中等,UC最低),同时将基线特征作为调节因素进行评估。在这些BCS(平均年龄57岁)中,73%为非西班牙裔白人,77%接受了化疗(CT)和放疗。所有组的认知表现均有改善。虽然在认知结果方面组间没有统计学上的显著差异,但MBSR(BC)组的症状有显著减轻(P = 0.003)。26周时的组内效应量分析表明,所有三组在主观损伤和生活质量(效应量>0.50)以及认知表现的客观测量方面都有显著改善(效应量>0.50)。MBSR(BC)组在减轻疲劳方面显示出最大的组内效应量(效应量 = 0.81)。18项结果中有10项的效应量出现在假设的方向上。虽然与BCES和UC相比,MBSR(BC)计划在认知表现上没有显示出显著差异,但所有组都有改善,且减轻疲劳对MBSR(BC)组有益。结果表明,考虑到自然病程,CT后认知表现可能会随时间改善。此外,参加RCT的BCS可能更有动力改善他们的健康状况(NCT02786797)。