Veterinary Epidemiology Unit, Department of Internal Medicine, Reproduction and Population Medicine, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Ghent University, Salisburylaan 133, Merelbeke 9820, Belgium.
Division of Environmental Health Sciences, School of Public Health, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN, United States.
Prev Vet Med. 2024 Dec;233:106348. doi: 10.1016/j.prevetmed.2024.106348. Epub 2024 Sep 18.
Monitoring antimicrobial use (AMU) is crucial, as it plays a key role in driving antimicrobial resistance (AMR). Animals account for a significant share of AMU, making it essential to accurately quantify AMU exposure at the species, farm, and country levels. In Pakistan, prophylactic use of antimicrobials remains common alongside therapeutic use. This study aimed to establish defined daily and course doses for both therapeutic and prophylactic use of antimicrobials in commercial broiler production in Pakistan. A list of antimicrobial products was compiled from the daily treatment records from 100 commercial broiler farms in Punjab, Pakistan. For each active substance (AS), a defined daily dose (DDD) was assigned for treatment, prevention or both, by averaging the recommended doses of all similar AS with the same administration route. A defined course dose (DCD) was calculated by multiplying the average recommended dose by the average treatment duration for each AS, based on the Summary of Product Characteristics (SmPC). A total of 41 AS, categorized into 17 antimicrobial classes, were identified from 139 antimicrobial products. The most frequently reported AS were colistin (polymyxins) at 15.9 %, amoxicillin (aminopenicillins) at 7.5 %, neomycin (aminoglycosides) at 7.3 %, enrofloxacin (fluoroquinolones) at 6.7 %, and tylosin (macrolides) at 6.4 % of the total treatments (n = 358) reported at farms. Notably, 51 % of AS were classified as critically important for human medicine by WHO. Among AS indicated for treatment in SmPC, the defined daily doses for Pakistan (DDD) varied substantially from the European Medicines Agency (EMA) values (DDD), with the top deviations being Tiamulin (+147.8 %), Sulfadimidine_TMP (+111.2 %), Flumequine (+88.6 %), Spiramycin (-87.8 %), and Tylosin (-84.3 %). This study presents a list of defined daily doses and defined course doses for AMU quantification in Pakistani broilers using dose-based indicators. The observed differences between Pakistani and EMA doses, and lack of EMA doses for preventive antimicrobials, suggest using Pakistani DDD values to quantify antimicrobial usage in Pakistan. A huge variation in recommended doses was reported in SmPC. There is an urgent need to establish a list of approved veterinary antimicrobials used in Pakistan, along with harmonization in recommended doses and maintenance of standardized SmPC by the drug regulatory authorities. Setting up a national-level list of defined daily doses is crucial to accurately monitor and quantify AMU.
监测抗菌药物使用(AMU)至关重要,因为它在推动抗菌药物耐药性(AMR)方面发挥着关键作用。动物在 AMU 中占有很大的比例,因此准确地量化物种、农场和国家层面的 AMU 暴露情况至关重要。在巴基斯坦,预防性使用抗菌药物与治疗性使用一样普遍。本研究旨在确定巴基斯坦商业肉鸡生产中治疗和预防使用抗菌药物的定义日剂量(DDD)和疗程剂量(DCD)。从巴基斯坦旁遮普省 100 家商业肉鸡养殖场的每日治疗记录中编制了一份抗菌药物产品清单。对于每种活性物质(AS),通过平均具有相同给药途径的所有类似 AS 的推荐剂量,为治疗、预防或两者分配一个定义的日剂量(DDD)。通过将平均推荐剂量乘以每种 AS 的平均治疗持续时间,根据产品特性摘要(SmPC)计算定义的疗程剂量(DCD)。从 139 种抗菌药物产品中确定了 41 种 AS,分为 17 种抗菌药物类别。从报告的 358 次治疗中,最常报告的 AS 是多粘菌素(多粘菌素),占 15.9%,阿莫西林(氨基青霉素)占 7.5%,新霉素(氨基糖苷类)占 7.3%,恩诺沙星(氟喹诺酮类)占 6.7%,泰乐菌素(大环内酯类)占 6.4%。值得注意的是,世界卫生组织(WHO)将 51%的 AS 列为对人类医学至关重要的药物。在 SmPC 中指出用于治疗的 AS 中,巴基斯坦的定义日剂量(DDD)与欧洲药品管理局(EMA)值(DDD)有很大差异,最大偏差为泰妙菌素(+147.8%)、磺胺嘧啶_TMP(+111.2%)、氟甲喹(+88.6%)、螺旋霉素(-87.8%)和泰乐菌素(-84.3%)。本研究使用基于剂量的指标,为巴基斯坦肉鸡提供了 AMU 量化的定义日剂量和定义疗程剂量的清单。巴基斯坦和 EMA 剂量之间存在差异,以及缺乏用于预防的 EMA 剂量,表明使用巴基斯坦 DDD 值来量化巴基斯坦的抗菌药物使用情况。SmPC 中报告了推荐剂量的巨大差异。迫切需要建立一份在巴基斯坦使用的批准兽医抗菌药物清单,并由药物监管机构协调推荐剂量并保持标准化的 SmPC。建立国家级定义日剂量清单对于准确监测和量化 AMU 至关重要。