Clare M J, Luckinbill L S
Heredity (Edinb). 1985 Aug;55 ( Pt 1):19-26. doi: 10.1038/hdy.1985.67.
Several previous attempts at selecting for increased life span with Drosophila have failed to obtain a response to selection, and postulate that life span is controlled by non-genetic maternal effects instead of genes. In other experiments, however, populations have responded. This study uses a set of true-breeding long- and short-lived stocks developed by in vitro selection to examine the effect on life span of developmental environment and outcrossing. The expression of genes for life span is shown here to vary as a result of a gene-environment interaction and is strongly affected by the environment during development. The longevity of F1 crosses between long- and short-lived parental lines is additive when the density of larvae is high and unfixed, showing that life span is controlled by genes and not nongenetic maternal effects. But, when numbers of larvae are held low and constant, as in studies where selection fails, life span of crosses and parental lines is greatly restricted. The failure of some previous attempts at selection, therefore, appears to have resulted from the introduction, through experimental design, of strong artifactual environmental effects that limit the phenotypic expression of genes for life span and the effectiveness of selection. Comparison of fecundity in parental and F1 lines shows that selection for increased life span antagonistically reduces early-life fecundity. Short-lived, parental lines, reproduced at an early age in life, lay 22-24 per cent more eggs in the same period than do long-lived lines selected for reproduction at a late age.
此前曾有几次尝试通过果蝇来选择延长寿命,但均未获得对选择的响应,并推测寿命是由非遗传的母体效应而非基因控制的。然而,在其他实验中,种群却出现了响应。本研究使用了一组通过体外选择培育出的纯合长寿和短寿品系,以检验发育环境和杂交对寿命的影响。结果表明,寿命相关基因的表达因基因 - 环境相互作用而有所不同,并且在发育过程中受到环境的强烈影响。当幼虫密度高且不固定时,长寿和短寿亲本品系之间的F1杂交后代的寿命是可加性的,这表明寿命是由基因控制的,而非非遗传的母体效应。但是,当幼虫数量保持低且恒定,就像在一些选择失败的研究中那样,杂交后代和亲本品系的寿命会受到极大限制。因此,之前一些选择尝试的失败似乎是由于实验设计引入了强烈的人为环境效应,这些效应限制了寿命相关基因的表型表达以及选择的有效性。对亲本品系和F1品系繁殖力的比较表明,选择延长寿命会拮抗地降低早期繁殖力。短寿的亲本品系在生命早期繁殖,在同一时期内产卵量比选择在生命后期繁殖的长寿品系多22 - 24%。