Hafid Shuaib, Isenberg Sarina R, Fernandes Aleisha, Gallagher Erin, Webber Colleen, Joseph Meera, Sood Manish M, Bruni Adrianna, Davis Janet L, Warmels Grace, Downar James, Gayowsky Anastasia, Jones Aaron, Manuel Doug, Tanuseputro Peter, Howard Michelle
Department of Family Medicine, McMaster University, Hamilton, ON, Canada.
Department of Medicine, University of Ottawa, ON, Canada.
Can J Kidney Health Dis. 2024 Sep 21;11:20543581241280698. doi: 10.1177/20543581241280698. eCollection 2024.
Nephrologists routinely provide end-of-life care for patients with kidney failure (KF) on maintenance dialysis. Involvement of primary care and palliative care physicians may enhance this experience.
The objective was to describe outpatient care patterns in the last year of life and the end-of-life acute care utilization for patients with KF on maintenance dialysis.
Retrospective cohort study using population-level health administrative data.
SETTING & PARTICIPANTS: Outpatient and inpatient care during the last year of life among patients who died between 2017 and 2019, receiving maintenance dialysis in Ontario, Canada.
The primary exposure is patterns of physician specialties providing outpatient care in the last year of life. Outcomes include outpatient encounters in the last year of life, acute care visitation in the last month of life, and place of death.
We reported the count and percentage of categorical outcomes and the median (interquartile range) for numeric outcomes. We produced time series plots of the mean monthly percentage of encounters to different specialties stratified by physician specialty patterns. We evaluated differences in outcomes by physician specialty patterns using analysis of variance (ANOVA) and Pearson's chi-square tests ( < .05, two-tailed).
Among 6866 patients, the median age at death was 73, 36.1% were female, and 87.8% resided in urban regions. Three patterns emerged: a primary care, nephrology, and palliative care triad (25.5%); a primary care and nephrology dyad (59.3%); and a non-primary care pattern (15.2%). Palliative care involvement is concentrated near death. Of all, 81.4% spent at least 1 day in hospital or emergency department in the last month, but those with primary care, palliative care, and nephrology involvement had the fewest acute care deaths (65.8%).
Outpatient care patterns were defined using physician billing codes, potentially missing care from other providers.
Nephrology and primary care predominantly manage outpatient care in the last year of life for patients with KF on maintenance dialysis, with consistent acute care use across care patterns except for the place of death. Future research should explore associations between patterns of care and end-of-life outcomes to identify the most optimal model of care for patients with KF on maintenance dialysis.
肾病科医生通常为接受维持性透析的肾衰竭(KF)患者提供临终关怀。初级保健医生和姑息治疗医生的参与可能会改善这种体验。
描述接受维持性透析的KF患者在生命最后一年的门诊护理模式以及临终急性护理的使用情况。
使用人群水平的健康管理数据进行回顾性队列研究。
2017年至2019年间在加拿大安大略省接受维持性透析并死亡的患者在生命最后一年的门诊和住院护理情况。
主要暴露因素是在生命最后一年提供门诊护理的医生专业模式。结局包括生命最后一年的门诊就诊次数、生命最后一个月的急性护理就诊次数以及死亡地点。
我们报告了分类结局的计数和百分比以及数值结局的中位数(四分位间距)。我们绘制了按医生专业模式分层的不同专业每月平均就诊百分比的时间序列图。我们使用方差分析(ANOVA)和Pearson卡方检验(<.05,双侧)评估不同医生专业模式下结局的差异。
在6866名患者中,死亡时的中位年龄为73岁,36.1%为女性,87.8%居住在城市地区。出现了三种模式:初级保健、肾病科和姑息治疗三元组(25.5%);初级保健和肾病科二元组(59.3%);以及非初级保健模式(15.2%)。姑息治疗的参与集中在临近死亡时。总体而言,81.4%的患者在生命最后一个月至少在医院或急诊科待了1天,但有初级保健、姑息治疗和肾病科参与的患者急性护理死亡人数最少(65.8%)。
门诊护理模式是使用医生计费代码定义的,可能遗漏了其他提供者的护理。
肾病科和初级保健在接受维持性透析的KF患者生命的最后一年主要管理门诊护理,除了死亡地点外,各护理模式的急性护理使用情况一致。未来的研究应探索护理模式与临终结局之间的关联,以确定接受维持性透析的KF患者的最佳护理模式。