Institute of Cognitive Neuroscience, University College London, London, UK.
School of Psychological Sciences, University of Newcastle, Sydney, Australia.
Sci Rep. 2024 Sep 27;14(1):22079. doi: 10.1038/s41598-024-73438-0.
Performing dance is an intrinsically social art form where at least one person moves while another person watches. Dancing in groups promotes social bonding, but how does group dance affect the people watching? A group of dancers and dance novices watched a 30 min dance video individually in an fMRI scanner. In a follow-up behavioural study, the same people watched the video again and provided continuous enjoyment ratings. Firstly, we computed cross-recurrence of continuous enjoyment ratings and inter-subject correlations (ISCs) in fMRI separately for both groups, and with the choreographer of the dance work. At both behavioural and neural levels, dancers responded more similarly to each other than novices. ISCs among dancers extended beyond brain areas involved in audio-visual integration and sensory areas of human movement perception into motor areas, suggesting greater sensorimotor familiarity with the observed dance movements in the expert group. Secondly, we show that dancers' brain activations and continuous ratings are more similar to the choreographer's ratings in keeping with sharing an aesthetic and artistic perspective when viewing the dance. Thirdly, we show that movement synchrony among performers is the best predictor of brain synchrony among both expert and novice spectators. This is consistent with the idea that changes in emergent movement synchrony are a key aesthetic feature of performing dance. Finally, ISCs across perceptual and motor brain areas were primarily driven by movement acceleration and synchrony, whereas ISCs in orbital and pre-frontal brain areas were overall weaker and better explained by the continuous enjoyment ratings of each group. Our findings provide strong evidence that the aesthetic appreciation of dance involves a common experience between dance spectators and the choreographer. Moreover, the similarity of brain activations and of enjoyment increases with shared knowledge of - and practice in - the artform that is being experienced, in this case contemporary performing dance.
舞蹈是一种本质上具有社交性的艺术形式,至少有一人在动,而另一人在观看。群体舞蹈可以促进社交联系,但集体舞蹈如何影响观看者呢?一组舞者和舞蹈新手在 fMRI 扫描仪中分别观看了 30 分钟的舞蹈视频。在后续的行为研究中,同样的人再次观看了视频,并提供了持续的享受评分。首先,我们分别为两组舞者和舞蹈新手计算了 fMRI 中连续享受评分和受试者间相关性 (ISCs) 的交叉重现,以及与舞蹈作品的编舞的交叉重现。在行为和神经水平上,舞者之间的反应比新手之间更相似。舞者之间的 ISC 不仅延伸到涉及视听整合的大脑区域和人类运动感知的感觉区域,而且延伸到运动区域,这表明专家组对观察到的舞蹈动作具有更大的运动感觉熟悉度。其次,我们表明,舞者的大脑激活和连续评分与编舞的评分更为相似,这与他们在观看舞蹈时具有共同的审美和艺术视角一致。第三,我们表明,表演者之间的运动同步性是专家和新手观众之间大脑同步性的最佳预测指标。这与新兴运动同步性的变化是表演舞蹈的关键审美特征的观点一致。最后,感知和运动大脑区域的 ISC 主要由运动加速度和同步性驱动,而眶额和前额叶大脑区域的 ISC 总体较弱,并且可以更好地由每组的连续享受评分来解释。我们的发现提供了强有力的证据,表明舞蹈的审美欣赏涉及舞蹈观众和编舞之间的共同体验。此外,随着对所体验的艺术形式(在这种情况下是当代表演舞蹈)的共同知识和实践的增加,大脑激活和享受的相似性也会增加。