Soboh Rashad, Rotfeld Meital, Gino-Moor Sharon, Jiries Nizar, Ginsberg Shira, Oliven Ron
Fliman Geriatric Hospital, Haifa 31021, Israel.
Geriatric Unit, Bnai Zion Medical Center, Haifa 3339419, Israel.
Brain Sci. 2024 Aug 27;14(9):862. doi: 10.3390/brainsci14090862.
Delirium is often the first symptom of incipient acute illness or complications and must therefore be detected promptly. Nevertheless, routine screening for delirium in acute care hospital wards is often inadequate. We recently implemented a simple, user-friendly delirium screening test (RMA) that can be administered during ward rounds and routine nursing care. The test was found to be non-inferior to 4AT in terms of sensitivity and specificity. However, the dominant factors to take into account when assessing the performance of a test added to the routine work of busy acute care hospital wards are ease of administration, real-life amenability and the ability of the staff to adhere to testing requirements. In this study, we evaluated the prevalence of daily RMA tests that were not administered as scheduled and the impact of these omissions on the overall real-world performance of RMA. Using point-in-time assessments of 4AT by an external rater, we found that complete RMA was administered in 88.8% of the days. Physicians omitted significantly more tests than nurses, but their results were more specific for delirium. Omissions reduced the sensitivity and specificity of RMA for delirium (compared to 4AT) from 90.7% to 81.7%, and from 99.2% to 87.8%, respectively. Ideally, the number of omitted RMA tests should be minimized. However, if over 85% of the daily quota of complete tests are administered, the sensitivity and specificity of RMA for diagnosing delirium as soon as it appears remain at acceptable levels.
谵妄往往是急性疾病初期或并发症的首发症状,因此必须及时发现。然而,在急性护理医院病房中,对谵妄进行常规筛查往往并不充分。我们最近实施了一种简单、便于使用的谵妄筛查测试(RMA),该测试可在查房和常规护理期间进行。结果发现,该测试在敏感性和特异性方面不劣于4AT。然而,在繁忙的急性护理医院病房的日常工作中评估一项测试的性能时,需要考虑的主要因素包括易于实施、符合实际情况以及工作人员遵守测试要求的能力。在本研究中,我们评估了未按计划进行每日RMA测试的发生率,以及这些遗漏对RMA整体实际性能的影响。通过外部评估者对4AT进行即时评估,我们发现88.8%的日子里完成了完整的RMA测试。医生遗漏的测试明显多于护士,但其结果对谵妄的特异性更高。遗漏使RMA对谵妄的敏感性和特异性(与4AT相比)分别从90.7%降至81.7%,从99.2%降至87.8%。理想情况下,应尽量减少遗漏的RMA测试数量。然而,如果完成的测试数量超过每日配额的85%,RMA对谵妄出现时的诊断敏感性和特异性仍处于可接受水平。