Rollison Julia, Miner Skye, Buenaventura Maya, Rabinowitz Maya
Rand Health Q. 2024 Sep 25;11(4):2. eCollection 2024 Sep.
The implementation and enforcement of state and local abortion policy can vary significantly between medical clinics and depend on the context and the individual decisionmakers involved. Research conducted prior to the U.S. Supreme Court decision in showed that, when providers are unclear about potentially conflicting or changing local and state policies (formal and informal) or enforcement, many err on the side of caution and become more restrictive in their practices. However, it is unknown whether and to what extent state and local policies and practices adapted in the wake of Dobbs have influenced providers' practices. The authors conducted an initial study of laws and policies post-Dobbs in one state, North Carolina, to better understand the policy landscape and gather perspectives from staff in facilities or organizations that provide or support abortion care. This study served as a unique opportunity to explore laws and policies, as well as implementation experiences, given North Carolina's Senate Bill 20, which instituted a gestational limit of 12 weeks and 6 days, as well as other provisions, including a 72-hour in-person consent requirement. The findings highlight the reported impacts of Senate Bill 20 on facilities, providers, and patients, as well as other local and institutional policies on abortion care access. This work highlights the importance of understanding legislation and its underlying provisions to ensure a complete picture of implementation factors and potential impacts.
州和地方堕胎政策的实施与执行在不同医疗诊所之间可能存在显著差异,这取决于具体情况以及相关的个体决策者。在美国最高法院于[具体年份]做出裁决之前进行的研究表明,当医疗服务提供者不清楚潜在冲突或不断变化的地方和州政策(正式和非正式)或执法情况时,许多人会出于谨慎行事,在实践中变得更加严格。然而,多布斯案后州和地方政策及做法是否以及在多大程度上影响了医疗服务提供者的实践尚不清楚。作者对北卡罗来纳州这一个州多布斯案后的法律和政策进行了初步研究,以更好地了解政策格局,并收集提供或支持堕胎护理的机构或组织工作人员的观点。鉴于北卡罗来纳州的参议院法案20设定了12周零6天的妊娠期限制以及其他条款,包括72小时亲自同意要求,这项研究提供了一个探索法律和政策以及实施经验的独特机会。研究结果突出了参议院法案20对机构、医疗服务提供者和患者的 reported 影响,以及其他地方和机构政策对堕胎护理可及性的影响。这项工作强调了理解立法及其基本条款以全面了解实施因素和潜在影响的重要性。