Lambert Imogen, Wright Nicola, Gardner Alison, Fyson Rachel, Abubakar Aisha, Clawson Rachael
University of Nottingham, UK.
Trauma Violence Abuse. 2025 Jul;26(3):468-482. doi: 10.1177/15248380241282993. Epub 2024 Oct 1.
Exploitation is a form of abuse that occurs when one person unfairly manipulates another for profit or personal gain. Various individual and social characteristics have the potential to increase an individual's risk of being exploited. Cognitive impairment is one potential vulnerability factor that has received minimal research attention. This scoping review aimed to investigate cognitive impairment as a factor that may increase an individual's vulnerability to exploitation. Study inclusion criteria were: (a) empirical studies; (b) studies presenting extractable data related to cognitive impairment and exploitation; (c) studies exploring cognitive impairment as a vulnerability factor for exploitation; (d) studies published after 1998; and (e) studies available in English. A six-step search strategy was employed: (a) electronic searches of bibliographic databases; (b) screening reference lists of included studies; (c) forward citation tracking in Google Scholar; (d) expert recommendations; (e) website searches of relevant Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs); and (f) a call for evidence. Twenty studies met the inclusion criteria. Three types of exploitation were reported: sexual ( = 10), financial ( = 8), and criminal ( = 2). Intellectual disability ( = 8) and mental health ( = 8) were the most frequently described forms of cognitive impairment. The results indicate that cognitive impairment is a factor that increases vulnerability to exploitation. However, the limited number and disparate nature of the studies means that it is impossible to disentangle all the complexities in the relationship between cognitive impairment and exploitation. Further research is needed to understand if cognitive impairment increases vulnerability to all types of exploitation or if it results in varying levels of susceptibility to different types of exploitation.
剥削是一种虐待形式,当一个人为了获利或个人利益而不公平地操纵另一个人时就会发生。各种个人和社会特征都有可能增加一个人被剥削的风险。认知障碍是一个潜在的脆弱因素,但受到的研究关注极少。本范围综述旨在调查认知障碍作为一个可能增加个体被剥削易感性的因素。研究纳入标准为:(a)实证研究;(b)呈现与认知障碍和剥削相关的可提取数据的研究;(c)将认知障碍作为剥削脆弱因素进行探索的研究;(d)1998年后发表的研究;(e)英文可得的研究。采用了六步搜索策略:(a)对书目数据库进行电子搜索;(b)筛选纳入研究的参考文献列表;(c)在谷歌学术中进行向前引文追踪;(d)专家推荐;(e)对相关非政府组织(NGO)网站进行搜索;(f)征集证据。20项研究符合纳入标准。报告了三种剥削类型:性剥削(=10)、金融剥削(=8)和刑事剥削(=2)。智力残疾(=8)和心理健康问题(=8)是最常被描述的认知障碍形式。结果表明,认知障碍是增加被剥削易感性的一个因素。然而,研究数量有限且性质各异,这意味着不可能理清认知障碍与剥削之间关系的所有复杂性。需要进一步研究以了解认知障碍是否会增加对所有类型剥削的易感性,或者它是否会导致对不同类型剥削的易感性程度不同。