Jacobson Michael Evan, Thibau Isabelle J, Baghoomian Wenelia, Latour Emile, Kastala Ajai, Loiselle Allison R, Simpson Eric Lawrence, Begolka Wendy Smith
Department of Dermatology Oregon Health & Science University Portland Oregon USA.
National Eczema Association Novato California USA.
Skin Health Dis. 2023 Jun 22;4(5):e259. doi: 10.1002/ski2.259. eCollection 2024 Oct.
Eczema clinical trials (CTs) are increasing in number, yet participation across the eczema community is low. Little is known about patient characteristics and views on motivators and barriers to CT participation (CTP).
Determine factors that motivate or impede participation in eczema CT and respondent characteristics associated with these factors.
Qualitative thematic analysis was performed on open-ended questions from an online survey that collected respondent demographics, understanding of and experience with CTs, and drivers/barriers to CTP. Mixed-methods analysis included 924 respondents, 728 (78.8%) adults with eczema and 196 (21.2%) caregivers of children with eczema.
A large proportion (71.8%) of respondents would potentially participate in CTs. The most common theme for why a respondent considered or would explore CTP was burden of disease (81.0% and 57.3% respectively). Among those who participated in or considered a CT, caregivers ( = 0.001) reported fewer altruistic motivations compared to adult patients, with trends towards men citing disease burden more (57.0% vs. 50.9%) and altruism less (14.5% vs. 19.2%) than women. Lack of awareness (57.7%) was the most common reason for never having considered a CT. Among those who never considered CTP, age ( = 0.012) and eczema severity at its worst ( = 0.002) were associated with reasons why they never participated. Specifically, older and less severe patients had greater perceptions of eligibility as a barrier to CTP. Caregivers more commonly cited fear of CT risks (20% vs. 11.4%) compared to adult patients who cited accessibility concerns (17.7% vs. 8.6%) as barriers to CT exploration. A subgroup of respondents that never considered CTP and extremely unlikely to consider CTs cited more fears/risks/unknowns and accessibility barriers to CTP. No significant differences in motivators or barriers were observed across race/ethnic groups and urban/rural populations.
Motivating factors for CTP include greater disease burden; lack of awareness represents a large barrier. Healthcare providers are trusted intermediaries with ability to refer and inform about CTs; they have a potentially significant role in raising awareness and discussing eczema patient/caregiver perspectives related to CTP. Investigators should tailor recruitment approaches and study design where possible to address identified motivators and barriers.
湿疹临床试验(CTs)的数量在不断增加,但整个湿疹群体的参与率较低。对于患者特征以及关于参与CT的动机和障碍的看法了解甚少。
确定促使或阻碍参与湿疹CT的因素以及与这些因素相关的受访者特征。
对一项在线调查中的开放式问题进行定性主题分析,该调查收集了受访者的人口统计学信息、对CT的理解和经验以及参与CT的驱动因素/障碍。混合方法分析包括924名受访者,其中728名(78.8%)为患有湿疹的成年人,196名(21.2%)为患有湿疹儿童的照顾者。
很大一部分(71.8%)受访者可能会参与CT。受访者考虑或会探索参与CT的最常见主题是疾病负担(分别为81.0%和57.3%)。在参与或考虑过CT的人中,与成年患者相比,照顾者报告的利他动机较少(P = 0.001),男性比女性更倾向于提及疾病负担(57.0%对50.9%),利他主义动机更少(14.5%对19.2%)。缺乏认知(57.7%)是从未考虑过CT的最常见原因。在从未考虑过参与CT的人中,年龄(P = 0.012)和最严重时的湿疹严重程度(P = 0.002)与他们从未参与的原因有关。具体而言,年龄较大和病情较轻的患者更认为符合条件是参与CT的障碍。与成年患者相比,照顾者更常提及对CT风险的担忧(20%对11.4%),而成年患者将可及性问题(17.7%对8.6%)视为探索CT的障碍。一个从未考虑过参与CT且极不可能考虑CT的受访者亚组提到了更多对参与CT的恐惧/风险/未知因素和可及性障碍。在种族/族裔群体和城市/农村人口中,未观察到动机或障碍方面的显著差异。
参与CT的驱动因素包括更大的疾病负担;缺乏认知是一个很大的障碍。医疗保健提供者是值得信赖的中介,有能力转介并告知CT相关信息;他们在提高认知以及讨论与参与CT相关的湿疹患者/照顾者观点方面可能发挥重要作用。研究人员应尽可能调整招募方法和研究设计,以解决已确定的驱动因素和障碍。