Department of Neurology, Gabriel Touré Teaching Hospital, Bamako, Mali.
Faculty of Medicine, University of Technical Sciences and Technologies, Bamako, Mali.
BMC Complement Med Ther. 2024 Oct 3;24(1):352. doi: 10.1186/s12906-024-04645-5.
Neurological disorders (ND) have a high incidence in sub-Saharan Africa (SSA). In this region, systemic challenges of conventional medicine (CM) and cultural beliefs have contributed to a large utilization of traditional medicine (TM). Yet, data on TM and those who use it in the treatment of ND in SSA are scarce. Here, we systematically analyze its role as a therapy modality for ND in Mali, the socio-demographic characteristics of its users, and propose next steps to optimize the dual usages of TM and CM for patients with ND.
We conducted a questionnaire study in two phases. In phase one, patients with ND answered questions on their usage of and attitudes towards TM. In phase two, the TM therapists who provided care to the patients in phase one answered questions regarding their own practices for treating ND. Patients were recruited from the country's two university neurology departments.
3,534 of the 4,532 patients seen in the Departments of Neurology in 2019 met the inclusion criteria. Among these 3,534 patients, 2,430 (68.8%) had previously consulted TM for their present ND. Patients over 60 years of age most often used TM (83.1%). By education, illiterate patients utilized TM the most (85.5%) while those with more than a secondary education used TM the least (48.6%). An income greater than the minimum guaranteed salary was associated with decreased use of traditional medicine (OR 0.29, CI 0.25-0.35, p < 0.001). Among those using TM, it was overwhelmingly thought to be more effective than CM (84.6%). Linking illness to supernatural causes and believing TM therapists had a better understanding of illnesses were the most common reasons patients used traditional medicine (82.3% and 80.5%, respectively). We then interviewed 171 TM therapists who had provided care to the patients in phase one. These providers most commonly "sometimes" (62.6%) referred patients to CM and 4.1% never had. A majority of TM providers (62.6%) believed collaboration with CM could be improved by having doctor "take into account" our existence.
Our work shows that TM plays a central role in the provision of care for patients with ND in SSA with certain cohorts using it at higher rates. Future development of treatment of ND in SSA will require optimizing TM with CM and needs buy-in from all stakeholders including conventional medicine clinicians, traditional medicine therapists, researchers, politicians, and most importantly, patients.
在撒哈拉以南非洲(SSA),神经疾病(ND)的发病率很高。在该地区,传统医学(CM)的系统挑战和文化信仰促成了对传统医学(TM)的大量利用。然而,关于 TM 以及该地区治疗 ND 时使用 TM 的人的数据却很少。在这里,我们系统地分析了 TM 在马里作为 ND 治疗方法的作用、其使用者的社会人口特征,并提出了优化 TM 和 CM 对 ND 患者双重使用的下一步措施。
我们分两个阶段进行了问卷调查研究。在第一阶段,ND 患者回答了关于他们使用 TM 和对 TM 的态度的问题。在第二阶段,为第一阶段的患者提供护理的 TM 治疗师回答了关于他们自己治疗 ND 的做法的问题。患者是从该国两所大学神经病学系招募的。
2019 年在神经病学系就诊的 4532 名患者中,有 3534 名符合纳入标准。在这 3534 名患者中,2430 名(68.8%)曾因目前的 ND 而咨询过 TM。60 岁以上的患者最常使用 TM(83.1%)。按教育程度划分,未受过教育的患者使用 TM 的比例最高(85.5%),而受过中等以上教育的患者使用 TM 的比例最低(48.6%)。收入高于最低工资保障线与传统医学使用率降低有关(OR 0.29,CI 0.25-0.35,p<0.001)。在使用 TM 的患者中,他们认为 TM 比 CM 更有效(84.6%)。将疾病与超自然原因联系起来,以及认为 TM 治疗师更了解疾病,是患者使用传统医学的最常见原因(分别为 82.3%和 80.5%)。然后,我们采访了 171 名曾为第一阶段患者提供护理的 TM 治疗师。这些提供者最常“有时”(62.6%)将患者转介给 CM,而 4.1%的人从不这样做。大多数 TM 提供者(62.6%)认为,通过让医生“考虑”我们的存在,可以改善与 CM 的合作。
我们的工作表明,TM 在为 SSA 的 ND 患者提供护理方面发挥着核心作用,某些人群的使用率更高。未来 SSA 的 ND 治疗的发展将需要优化 TM 与 CM 的结合,并需要包括传统医学临床医生、传统医学治疗师、研究人员、政治家在内的所有利益相关者的参与,最重要的是,患者的参与。