Ye Junhua, Huang Qinguo, Zhou Qiang, Li Hong, Peng Lin, Qi Songtao, Lu Yuntao
Department of Neurosurgery, Nanfang Hospital, Southern Medical University, Guangzhou, China.
Department of Neurosurgery, Meizhou People's Hospital (Huangtang Hospital), Meizhou, China.
Neurospine. 2024 Sep;21(3):1014-1028. doi: 10.14245/ns.2448622.311. Epub 2024 Sep 30.
Recent studies indicate that 3 morphological types of atlanto-occipital joint (AOJ) exist in the craniovertebral junction and are associated with type II basilar invagination (BI) and atlanto-occipital instability. However, the actual biomechanical effects remain unclear. This study aims to investigate biomechanical differences among AOJ types I, II, and III, and provide further evidence of atlanto-occipital instability in type II BI.
Models of bilateral AOJ containing various AOJ types were created, including I-I, I-II, II-II, II-III, and III-III models, with increasing AOJ dysplasia across models. Then, 1.5 Nm torque simulated cervical motions. The range of motion (ROM), ligament and joint stress, and basion-dental interval (BDI) were analyzed.
The C0-1 ROM and accompanying rotational ROM increased progressively from model I-I to model III-III, with the ROM of model III-III showing increases between 27.3% and 123.8% indicating ultra-mobility and instability. In contrast, the C1-2 ROM changes were minimal. Meanwhile, the stress distribution pattern was disrupted; in particular, the C1 superior facet stress was concentrated centrally and decreased substantially across the models. The stress on the C0-1 capsule ligament decreased during cervical flexion and increased during bending and rotating loading. In addition, BDI gradually decreased across the models. Further analysis revealed that the dens showed an increase of 110.1% superiorly and 11.4% posteriorly, indicating an increased risk of spinal cord impingement.
Progressive AOJ incongruity critically disrupts supportive tissue loading, enabling incremental atlanto-occipital instability. AOJ dysplasia plays a key biomechanical role in the pathogenesis of type II BI.
近期研究表明,颅骨与颈椎交界处存在三种形态类型的寰枕关节(AOJ),且与II型基底凹陷(BI)及寰枕关节不稳定相关。然而,其实际生物力学效应仍不明确。本研究旨在探究I型、II型和III型AOJ之间的生物力学差异,并为II型BI中寰枕关节不稳定提供进一步证据。
创建包含各种AOJ类型的双侧AOJ模型,包括I-I、I-II、II-II、II-III和III-III模型,各模型间AOJ发育异常程度逐渐增加。然后,用1.5 Nm扭矩模拟颈椎运动。分析运动范围(ROM)、韧带和关节应力以及基底齿间距(BDI)。
从I-I模型到III-III模型,C0-1的ROM及伴随的旋转ROM逐渐增加,III-III模型的ROM增加了27.3%至123.8%,表明存在过度活动和不稳定。相比之下,C1-2的ROM变化极小。同时,应力分布模式被破坏;特别是,C1上关节面应力集中在中央,且在各模型中大幅降低。C0-1关节囊韧带在颈椎前屈时应力降低,在侧弯和旋转负荷时应力增加。此外,各模型间BDI逐渐减小。进一步分析显示,齿突向上增加了110.1%,向后增加了11.4%,表明脊髓受压风险增加。
进行性AOJ不协调严重破坏了支持组织的负荷,导致寰枕关节不稳定逐渐增加。AOJ发育异常在II型BI的发病机制中起关键的生物力学作用。