Department of Occupational Science & Occupational Therapy, Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
The KITE Research Institute, Toronto Rehabilitation Institute-University Health Network, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
PLoS One. 2024 Oct 4;19(10):e0309148. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0309148. eCollection 2024.
Peer support programs demonstrate numerous benefits, including emotional, instrumental, informational, and affirmational social support. Since the COVID-19 pandemic, many peer support stroke programs in Canada have been delivered virtually. Compassion must be consistently applied to build meaningful interactions, but the shift to virtual services may have changed the quality of interaction and compassion in virtual services. While compassion is recommended in health and social services to improve outcomes, satisfaction, and service quality, compassion in virtual peer support stroke programs remains understudied. We aimed to describe compassionate support in virtual peer support stroke programs from peer support providers' and recipients' perspectives.
This qualitative descriptive study was guided by Sinclair & colleagues' model of compassion. Peer support recipients or peer support providers participated in interviews transcribed and analyzed using a hybrid thematic analysis.
Sixteen were peer support recipients, six were peer support providers, and two were both peer support providers and recipients. Participants agreed that compassion was essential in these programs. Participants perceived compassion to be a result of the virtues of compassionate facilitators (i.e., genuineness, passion, and empathy), relational space, and communication within the virtual peer support stroke program (e.g., sense of awareness or intuition of compassion, aspects of engaged peer support provision), virtuous response (e.g., knowing the person and actions that made the peer support recipient feel like a priority). Compassion was facilitated by listening and understanding peer support recipients' needs as they relate to stroke (i.e., seeking to understand peer support recipients and their needs), attending to peer support recipients' needs (e.g., timely actions to address their needs), and achieving compassion-related program outcomes (e.g., alleviating challenges and enhancing wellbeing). The absence of these components (e.g., lacking genuineness, passion and empathy) was a barrier to compassion in virtual peer support stroke programs.
Study findings describe facilitators and barriers to perceived compassion in virtual peer support stroke programs and provide practical recommendations that can be adapted into programs to improve program quality.
同伴支持计划显示出许多益处,包括情感、工具、信息和肯定性的社会支持。自 COVID-19 大流行以来,加拿大许多同伴支持中风计划已在网上进行。建立有意义的互动必须始终贯穿着同情心,但向虚拟服务的转变可能改变了虚拟服务中互动和同情心的质量。虽然同情心在卫生和社会服务中被推荐用于改善结果、满意度和服务质量,但虚拟同伴支持中风计划中的同情心仍研究不足。我们旨在从同伴支持提供者和接受者的角度描述虚拟同伴支持中风计划中的同情支持。
本定性描述性研究以 Sinclair 等人的同情心模型为指导。同伴支持接受者或同伴支持提供者参与了访谈,访谈记录经过转录,并使用混合主题分析进行了分析。
16 名是同伴支持接受者,6 名是同伴支持提供者,2 名既是同伴支持提供者又是接受者。参与者一致认为,这些计划中同情心至关重要。参与者认为同情心是有同情心的促进者(即真诚、热情和同理心)、关系空间和虚拟同伴支持中风计划中的沟通(例如,对同情心的意识或直觉、参与式同伴支持提供的方面)的结果。良性反应(例如,了解个人和使同伴支持接受者感到自己是优先事项的行动)。通过倾听和理解同伴支持接受者与中风相关的需求(即,努力了解同伴支持接受者及其需求)、关注同伴支持接受者的需求(例如,及时采取行动满足他们的需求)和实现与同情心相关的计划成果(例如,缓解挑战和增强幸福感)来促进同情心。缺乏这些组成部分(例如,缺乏真诚、热情和同理心)是虚拟同伴支持中风计划中同情心的障碍。
研究结果描述了虚拟同伴支持中风计划中感知到的同情心的促进因素和障碍,并提供了可适应于计划以提高计划质量的实际建议。