Department of Neurology, Hospital Clinico San Carlos, San Carlos Institute for Health Research (IdiSSC), Universidad Complutense, ES, Madrid 28040, Spain; Department of Biological and Health Psychology, Faculty of Psychology, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Madrid, Spain.
Department of Computer Architecture and Automation, Faculty of Informatics, Universidad Complutense, Madrid, Spain.
Mult Scler Relat Disord. 2024 Nov;91:105907. doi: 10.1016/j.msard.2024.105907. Epub 2024 Sep 25.
The European Cross-Cultural Neuropsychological Test Battery (CNTB) has been proposed as a comprehensive battery for cognitive assessment, reducing the potential impact of cultural variables. In this validation study, we aimed to evaluate the diagnostic capacity of CNTB for the assessment of participants with multiple sclerosis (pwMS) compared to the Neuronorma battery (NN) according to the International Classification of Cognitive Disorders in MS criteria, and to develop machine learning (ML) algorithms to improve the diagnostic capacity of CNTB and to select the most relevant tests.
Sixty pwMS and 60 healthy controls (HC) with no differences in sex, age, or years of education were enrolled. All participants completed the CNTB and pwMS were also examined with NN, depression, and fatigue scales. Impaired domains and cognitive phenotypes were defined following ICCoDiMS based on CNTB scores and compared to NN, according to -1SD and -1.5SD cutoff scores. To select the most relevant tests, random forest (RF) was performed for different binary classifications.
PwMS showed a lower performance compared to HC with medium-large effect sizes, in episodic memory, executive function, attention, and processing speed, in accordance with their characteristic cognitive profile. There were no differences in impaired domains or cognitive phenotypes between CNTB and NN, highlighting the role of episodic memory, executive function, attention, and processing speed tests. The most relevant tests identified by RF were consistent with inter-group comparisons and allowed a better classification than SD cutoff scores.
CNTB is a valid test for cognitive diagnosis in pwMS, including key tests for the most frequently impaired cognitive domains in MS. The use of ML techniques may also be useful to improve diagnosis, especially in some tests with lower sensitivity.
欧洲跨文化神经心理测试电池(CNTB)已被提议作为认知评估的综合电池,以减少文化变量的潜在影响。在这项验证研究中,我们旨在根据 MS 国际认知障碍分类标准评估 CNTB 对多发性硬化症(pwMS)参与者的诊断能力,并与 Neuronorma 电池(NN)进行比较,并开发机器学习(ML)算法来提高 CNTB 的诊断能力,并选择最相关的测试。
纳入了 60 名 pwMS 和 60 名健康对照组(HC),他们在性别、年龄或受教育年限方面没有差异。所有参与者都完成了 CNTB,pwMS 还接受了 NN、抑郁和疲劳量表的检查。根据基于 CNTB 分数的 ICCoDiMS,定义了受损域和认知表型,并与 NN 进行了比较,根据 -1SD 和 -1.5SD 截止分数。为了选择最相关的测试,对不同的二分类进行了随机森林(RF)。
pwMS 的表现与 HC 相比,存在中等至较大的差异,在情景记忆、执行功能、注意力和处理速度方面,符合其特征认知特征。CNTB 和 NN 之间在受损域或认知表型方面没有差异,突出了情景记忆、执行功能、注意力和处理速度测试的作用。RF 识别的最相关测试与组间比较一致,并且比 SD 截止分数允许更好的分类。
CNTB 是 pwMS 认知诊断的有效测试,包括 MS 中最常受损认知域的关键测试。使用 ML 技术也可能有助于提高诊断能力,尤其是在某些敏感性较低的测试中。