Université Paris Cité et Université Sorbonne Paris Nord, Inserm, IAME, Paris, France.
Antibioclic Steering Committee, Paris, France.
J Med Internet Res. 2024 Oct 7;26:e45122. doi: 10.2196/45122.
Suboptimal use of antimicrobials is a driver of antimicrobial resistance in West Africa. Clinical decision support systems (CDSSs) can facilitate access to updated and reliable recommendations.
This study aimed to assess contextual factors that could facilitate the implementation of a CDSS for antimicrobial prescribing in West Africa and Central Africa and to identify tailored implementation strategies.
This qualitative study was conducted through 21 semistructured individual interviews via videoconference with health care professionals between September and December 2020. Participants were recruited using purposive sampling in a transnational capacity-building network for hospital preparedness in West Africa. The interview guide included multiple constructs derived from the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research. Interviews were transcribed, and data were analyzed using thematic analysis.
The panel of participants included health practitioners (12/21, 57%), health actors trained in engineering (2/21, 10%), project managers (3/21, 14%), antimicrobial resistance research experts (2/21, 10%), a clinical microbiologist (1/21, 5%), and an anthropologist (1/21, 5%). Contextual factors influencing the implementation of eHealth tools existed at the individual, health care system, and national levels. At the individual level, the main challenge was to design a user-centered CDSS adapted to the prescriber's clinical routine and structural constraints. Most of the participants stated that the CDSS should not only target physicians in academic hospitals who can use their network to disseminate the tool but also general practitioners, primary care nurses, midwives, and other health care workers who are the main prescribers of antimicrobials in rural areas of West Africa. The heterogeneity in antimicrobial prescribing training among prescribers was a significant challenge to the use of a common CDSS. At the country level, weak pharmaceutical regulations, the lack of official guidelines for antimicrobial prescribing, limited access to clinical microbiology laboratories, self-medication, and disparity in health care coverage lead to inappropriate antimicrobial use and could limit the implementation and diffusion of CDSS for antimicrobial prescribing. Participants emphasized the importance of building a solid eHealth ecosystem in their countries by establishing academic partnerships, developing physician networks, and involving diverse stakeholders to address challenges. Additional implementation strategies included conducting a local needs assessment, identifying early adopters, promoting network weaving, using implementation advisers, and creating a learning collaborative. Participants noted that a CDSS for antimicrobial prescribing could be a powerful tool for the development and dissemination of official guidelines for infectious diseases in West Africa.
These results suggest that a CDSS for antimicrobial prescribing adapted for nonspecialized prescribers could have a role in improving clinical decisions. They also confirm the relevance of adopting a cross-disciplinary approach with participants from different backgrounds to assess contextual factors, including social, political, and economic determinants.
在西非,抗菌药物的使用不当是导致抗菌药物耐药性的一个驱动因素。临床决策支持系统(CDSS)可以帮助获取更新和可靠的建议。
本研究旨在评估在西非和中非实施抗菌药物处方 CDSS 的促进因素,并确定有针对性的实施策略。
这是一项通过视频会议于 2020 年 9 月至 12 月间对 21 名卫生保健专业人员进行的半结构式个体访谈的定性研究。参与者是通过在西非的医院备灾跨国能力建设网络进行有目的抽样招募的。访谈指南包括源自实施研究综合框架的多个构建。对访谈进行了转录,并使用主题分析进行了数据分析。
参与小组的成员包括卫生从业者(21 人中有 12 人,占 57%)、接受过工程培训的卫生行为者(21 人中有 2 人,占 10%)、项目经理(21 人中有 3 人,占 14%)、抗菌药物耐药性研究专家(21 人中有 2 人,占 10%)、临床微生物学家(21 人中有 1 人,占 5%)和人类学家(21 人中有 1 人,占 5%)。影响电子健康工具实施的因素存在于个人、医疗保健系统和国家层面。在个人层面,主要挑战是设计一个以用户为中心的 CDSS,使其适应开方者的临床常规和结构限制。大多数参与者表示,CDSS 不仅应针对学术医院的医生,因为他们可以利用自己的网络来传播该工具,还应针对农村地区的普通医生、初级保健护士、助产士和其他卫生保健工作者,因为他们是抗菌药物的主要开方者。开方者之间对抗菌药物处方培训的异质性是使用通用 CDSS 的一个重大挑战。在国家层面,薄弱的药品监管、缺乏抗菌药物处方的官方指南、临床微生物学实验室的有限获取、自我用药以及卫生保健覆盖范围的差异导致了不适当的抗菌药物使用,并可能限制抗菌药物处方 CDSS 的实施和传播。参与者强调通过建立学术伙伴关系、发展医生网络和纳入不同利益相关者来建立稳固的电子健康生态系统的重要性,以应对挑战。其他实施策略包括进行本地需求评估、确定早期采用者、促进网络编织、使用实施顾问和创建学习协作。参与者指出,抗菌药物处方 CDSS 可能是在西非制定和传播传染病官方指南的有力工具。
这些结果表明,针对非专业开方者的抗菌药物处方 CDSS 可以在改善临床决策方面发挥作用。它们还证实了采用跨学科方法的相关性,让来自不同背景的参与者共同评估社会、政治和经济等方面的背景因素。