National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD, USA.
Division of Biostatistics, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN, USA.
Lancet Microbe. 2024 Nov;5(11):100923. doi: 10.1016/S2666-5247(24)00163-0. Epub 2024 Oct 4.
rVSVΔG-ZEBOV-GP is the first approved vaccine with clinical efficacy against Ebola virus disease. Although a seroprotective threshold has not been defined for those at occupational risk of exposure, the current vaccine strategy is to attain a sustained high level of antibody titres. The aim of this trial was to explore the effects of delayed boosting upon both the height and duration of antibody titres following primary immunisation.
In this open-label phase 2 randomised controlled trial, we compared antibody titres at month 36 in participants who had received a homologous booster dose at month 18 following primary immunisation with those who had received no booster. From Oct 25, 2016, to Jan 29, 2020, healthy adults aged 18 years or older deemed at occupational risk of exposure to Ebola virus due to laboratory work, clinical duties, or travel to an active endemic region were recruited from four hospital clinics in the USA and one hospital clinic in Canada and received primary vaccination with 2×10 plaque-forming unit per mL of VSVΔG-ZEBOV-GP. 18 months later, individuals who consented and were still eligible were randomly assigned 1:1 to receive either a homologous booster dose or no booster. Study visits for safety and serial blood collections for antibody titres were done on enrolled participants at months 0, 1, 3, 6, 12, 18, 19, 24, 30, and 36. Through July, 2021, a web-based application was used for randomisation, including assignments with schedules for each of the five sites using mixed permuted blocks. The trial was not masked to participants or site staff. The primary endpoint was a comparison of geometric mean titres (GMTs) of anti-Ebola virus glycoprotein IgG antibody at month 36 (ie, 18 months after randomisation) for all randomly assigned participants who completed the 36 months of follow-up (primary analysis cohort). Investigators were aware of antibody titres from baseline (enrolment) through month 18 but were masked to summary data by randomisation group after month 18. This study is registered with ClinicalTrials.gov (NCT02788227).
Of the 248 participants who enrolled and received their primary immunisation, 114 proceeded to the randomisation step at month 18. The two randomisation groups were balanced: 57 participants (24 [42%] of whom were female; median age was 42 years [IQR 35-50]) were randomly assigned to the booster group and 57 (24 [42%] of whom were female; median age was 42 years [IQR 36-51]) to the no-booster group. Of those randomly assigned, 92 participants (45 in the booster group and 47 in the no-booster group) completed 36 months of follow-up. At 18 months after primary immunisation, GMTs in the no-booster group increased from a baseline of 10 ELISA units (EU)/mL (95% CI 7-14) to 1451 EU/mL (1118-1882); GMTs in the booster group increased from 9 EU/mL (6-16) to 1769 EU/mL (1348-2321). At month 19, GMTs were 31 408 EU/mL (23 181-42 554) for the booster group and 1406 EU/mL (1078-1833) for the no-booster group; at month 36, GMTs were 10 146 EU/mL (7960-12 933) for the booster group and 1240 EU/mL (984-1563) for the no-booster group. Accordingly, the geometric mean ratio (GMR) of antibody titres had increased almost 21-fold more in the booster versus no-booster group at 1 month after booster administration (GMR 20·6; 95% CI 18·2-23·0; p<0·0001) and was still over 7-fold higher at month 36 (GMR 7·8; 95% CI 5·5-10·2; p<0·0001). Consistent with previous reports of this vaccine's side-effects, transient mono-articular or oligo-articular arthritis was diagnosed in 18 (9%) of 207 primary vaccination recipients; after randomisation, arthritis was diagnosed in one (2%) of 57 participants in the no-booster group. No new cases of arthritis developed after booster administration. Four serious adverse events occurred following randomisation: one (epistaxis) in the booster group and three (gastrointestinal haemorrhage, prostate cancer, and tachyarrhythmia) in the no-booster group. None of the serious adverse events was judged attributable to the booster vaccination assignment.
In addition to no new safety concerns and in marked contrast to earlier trials evaluating short-term boosting, delaying a rVSVΔG-ZEBOV-GP booster until month 18 resulted in an increase in GMT that remained several-fold above the no-booster group GMT for at least 18 months. These findings could have implications for defining the optimal timing of booster doses as pre-exposure prophylaxis in populations at ongoing risk for Ebola virus exposure.
The Division of Intramural Research and the Division of Clinical Research of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases at the US National Institutes of Health, Canadian Immunization Research Network through the Public Health Agency of Canada, Canadian Institutes of Health Research, and the US Defense Threat Reduction Agency.
rVSVΔG-ZEBOV-GP 是首个获得埃博拉病毒病临床疗效批准的疫苗。虽然针对有职业性接触风险的人群尚未定义保护性抗体效价的阈值,但目前的疫苗策略是达到持续高水平的抗体滴度。本试验旨在探索初次免疫后延迟加强免疫对抗体滴度的高度和持续时间的影响。
在这项开放标签的 2 期随机对照试验中,我们比较了初次免疫后 18 个月时接受同源加强免疫的参与者与未接受加强免疫的参与者在第 36 个月时的抗体滴度。2016 年 10 月 25 日至 2020 年 1 月 29 日,美国四家医院诊所和加拿大一家医院诊所招募了年龄在 18 岁或以上、因实验室工作、临床职责或前往流行地区旅行而被认为有职业性接触埃博拉病毒风险的健康成年人,并接受了 2×10 噬菌斑形成单位/mL 的 VSVΔG-ZEBOV-GP 初次接种。18 个月后,同意并仍符合条件的个体被随机分配 1:1 接受同源加强免疫或不接受加强免疫。在接种的参与者中,每月进行一次安全性和连续血样采集,以检测抗体滴度。
在 248 名接种并完成初次免疫的参与者中,有 114 名进入了第 18 个月的随机分组步骤。两组随机分组平衡:57 名参与者(其中 24 名[42%]为女性;中位年龄为 42 岁[IQR 35-50])被随机分配到加强免疫组,57 名参与者(其中 24 名[42%]为女性;中位年龄为 42 岁[IQR 36-51])被随机分配到非加强免疫组。在随机分组的参与者中,92 名参与者(加强免疫组 45 名,非加强免疫组 47 名)完成了 36 个月的随访。初次免疫后 18 个月,非加强免疫组的抗体滴度从基线的 10 ELISA 单位(EU)/mL(95%CI 7-14)增加到 1451 EU/mL(1118-1882);加强免疫组的抗体滴度从 9 EU/mL(6-16)增加到 1769 EU/mL(1348-2321)。第 19 个月时,加强免疫组的抗体滴度为 31408 EU/mL(23181-42554),非加强免疫组为 1406 EU/mL(1078-1833);第 36 个月时,加强免疫组的抗体滴度为 10146 EU/mL(7960-12124),非加强免疫组为 1240 EU/mL(984-1563)。因此,加强免疫后 1 个月时,加强免疫组与非加强免疫组的抗体滴度几何平均比值(GMR)增加了近 21 倍(GMR 20.6;95%CI 18.2-23.0;p<0.0001),第 36 个月时仍增加了 7 倍以上(GMR 7.8;95%CI 5.5-10.2;p<0.0001)。与该疫苗先前报告的副作用一致,初次接种后 207 名接受者中有 18 名(9%)诊断出单关节或寡关节一过性关节炎;随机分组后,非加强免疫组有 1 名(2%)参与者诊断出关节炎。加强免疫后无新的关节炎病例发生。随机分组后发生了 4 例严重不良事件:加强免疫组 1 例(鼻出血),非加强免疫组 3 例(胃肠道出血、前列腺癌和心动过速)。没有一例严重不良事件被认为与加强免疫接种有关。
除了没有新的安全性问题外,与早期评估短期加强免疫的试验相比,将 rVSVΔG-ZEBOV-GP 加强免疫推迟到第 18 个月,导致 GMT 增加,至少在 18 个月内,GMT 仍保持在非加强免疫组的数倍以上。这些发现可能对确定埃博拉病毒暴露风险人群的最佳加强免疫时机作为暴露前预防具有重要意义。
美国国立卫生研究院过敏与传染病研究所的内部研究部门和临床研究部门、加拿大免疫研究网络(通过加拿大公共卫生署)、加拿大卫生研究院和美国国防威胁降低局。