School of Health Sciences, College of Health Sciences, Makerere University, Kampala, Uganda.
Int J Equity Health. 2024 Oct 7;23(1):201. doi: 10.1186/s12939-024-02294-1.
Transgender individuals often face stigma, discrimination, and various forms of abuse, which negatively impact their mental and physical health. They face a significantly greater risk of HIV, with a higher prevalence than the general population. Despite these challenges, transgender people have limited access to healthcare due to violence, legal barriers, and societal stigma, further exacerbated in countries like Uganda, where transgender identities are criminalized. Therefore, this study explored the lived experiences of HIV researchers working with gender minority populations in criminalizing contexts.
This was an interpretative phenomenological analysis (IPA) qualitative study. Twelve (12) research team members at all levels were involved in the study. Participants had less than five years of involvement in HIV research among gender minority populations. Data were collected using field notes, reflective journals, documentation from daily team debriefing sessions, and semi-structured interviews. The analysis used NVivo software.
Positive experiences, barriers, and challenges were captured. The positive experiences were 'respecting cultural diversity', 'expanding networks', 'addressing misconceptions' and 'finding allies'. The barriers included 'experiencing stigma', 'lengthy research processes', 'feeling isolated', 'fearing for personal safety', 'unexpected logistical costs', and 'criminalization of sexual and gender minorities'. The key themes that emerged from the lessons learned were: 'dealing with gatekeepers', 'diversity and sensitivity training', 'leveraging networks', 'meaningful community engagement', 'reflexivity', 'ensuring safety', 'equal partnership', 'giving feedback' and 'awareness of legal implications'.
This study highlights the importance of cultural sensitivity, community engagement, and reflexivity in research design and implementation. The findings emphasize the need for innovative strategies to navigate legal, social, and logistical barriers that researchers and participants face. Despite these challenges, the study demonstrates that meaningful collaboration with community members and building trust can significantly enhance the research process and outcomes. Future research should continue to explore these strategies while addressing ethical and safety concerns.
跨性别者经常面临污名化、歧视和各种形式的虐待,这些问题对他们的身心健康产生了负面影响。他们感染艾滋病毒的风险显著增加,感染率高于普通人群。尽管面临这些挑战,但由于暴力、法律障碍和社会污名化,跨性别者获得医疗保健的机会有限,在乌干达等国家,跨性别者的身份被定为犯罪,这一情况进一步恶化。因此,本研究探讨了在刑事定罪背景下,从事性别少数群体工作的艾滋病毒研究人员的生活经历。
这是一项解释性现象学分析(IPA)定性研究。研究涉及所有级别的 12 名(12)研究团队成员。参与者从事艾滋病毒研究中性别少数群体的工作时间不到五年。数据收集使用现场记录、反思日志、日常团队汇报会议记录和半结构化访谈。分析使用 NVivo 软件。
研究记录了积极的经验、障碍和挑战。积极的经验包括“尊重文化多样性”、“扩展网络”、“纠正误解”和“寻找盟友”。障碍包括“经历污名化”、“冗长的研究过程”、“感到孤立”、“担心个人安全”、“意外的后勤成本”和“对性和性别少数群体的刑事定罪”。从经验中得出的主要主题包括:“与把关人打交道”、“多样性和敏感性培训”、“利用网络”、“有意义的社区参与”、“反思”、“确保安全”、“平等伙伴关系”、“给予反馈”和“了解法律影响”。
本研究强调了在研究设计和实施中文化敏感性、社区参与和反思的重要性。研究结果强调了需要创新策略来应对研究人员和参与者面临的法律、社会和后勤障碍。尽管面临这些挑战,但研究表明,与社区成员建立有意义的合作关系并建立信任可以显著增强研究过程和结果。未来的研究应继续探讨这些策略,同时解决伦理和安全问题。