Shanmugam Subbiah, Pravenkumar R R
Dept of Surgical Oncology, Govt Royapettah Hospital, Kilpauk Medical College, Chennai, Tamilnadu 600014 India.
J Maxillofac Oral Surg. 2024 Oct;23(5):1063-1071. doi: 10.1007/s12663-024-02324-z. Epub 2024 Sep 3.
Oral cancer surgery and the associated reconstructive procedures cause mechanical and neurological impairment of swallowing. Despite postoperative rehabilitation, functional impairment of swallowing remains a concern. This study is to investigate the potential benefits of prehabilitation with preoperative swallowing exercises to patients undergoing composite resections and compartmental tongue resections so that it results in better swallowing outcomes and improved quality of life after surgery.
Sixty patients included in the study were randomized into an exercise and control group of 30 each. Patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the oral cavity undergoing composite resection or compartmental tongue resections were included, and patients with severe trismus at presentation were excluded. Patients in the exercise group were instructed on a set of six active exercises to be followed strictly for a period of at least 1 week before surgery. Preoperative swallowing exercises comprised of evidence-based exercises targeting the muscle groups involved in swallowing. Postoperative swallowing rehabilitation was the same as that of the control group. Patients were assessed after 6 months of surgery. Outcomes were assessed both subjectively and objectively. Objective assessment was done by inexpensive, novel clinical methods of repetitive saliva swallow test (RSST), water swallow test (WST) and food swallow test (FST) to and graded using dysphagia severity scale (1-7).
Average oral intake scale (1-Oral solids, 2-Oral semisolids/easy to chew foods, 3-Oral liquids only and 4-Non-oral, orogastric tube dependent) assessed subjectively was significantly lower in exercise arm, and the control arm had a significantly higher OIS score. Exercise arm had higher number of patients in DSS scores of 5, 6 and 7. The control arm had a higher number of patients in DSS scores of 3 and 4. The differences between the two groups were found to be statistically significant taking into consideration the confounding factors of radiation, wound morbidity and tongue resections.
Preoperative swallowing exercises have shown a positive impact on postoperative swallowing ability. This is the first randomized trial to assess the effect of PSE in postoperative oral cancer patients. Our exercise protocol needs standardization, and clinical objective method of dysphagia assessment requires further validation. However, prehabilitation with PSE has the potential to improve the quality of life in oral cancer patients.
口腔癌手术及相关重建手术会导致吞咽功能出现机械性和神经性损伤。尽管术后进行了康复治疗,但吞咽功能障碍仍是一个令人担忧的问题。本研究旨在探讨术前吞咽训练进行预康复对接受复合切除术和分区舌切除术患者的潜在益处,以期术后获得更好的吞咽效果并改善生活质量。
纳入研究的60例患者被随机分为运动组和对照组,每组30例。纳入接受复合切除术或分区舌切除术的口腔鳞状细胞癌患者,排除就诊时存在严重牙关紧闭的患者。运动组患者在术前至少1周内接受一组六项主动运动训练,并严格遵循。术前吞咽训练包括针对吞咽相关肌群的循证训练。术后吞咽康复与对照组相同。术后6个月对患者进行评估。通过主观和客观两种方式评估结果。客观评估采用廉价且新颖的临床方法,即重复唾液吞咽试验(RSST)、水吞咽试验(WST)和食物吞咽试验(FST),并使用吞咽困难严重程度量表(1 - 7级)进行分级。
主观评估的平均经口摄入量量表(1 - 经口固体食物,2 - 经口半固体食物/易咀嚼食物,3 - 仅经口液体食物,4 - 非经口,依赖鼻胃管)在运动组显著更低,而对照组的经口摄入量量表得分显著更高。运动组在吞咽困难严重程度量表得分为5、6和7分的患者数量更多。对照组在吞咽困难严重程度量表得分为3和4分的患者数量更多。考虑到放疗、伤口并发症和舌切除术等混杂因素,两组之间的差异具有统计学意义。
术前吞咽训练对术后吞咽能力产生了积极影响。这是第一项评估术前吞咽训练对口腔癌术后患者影响的随机试验。我们的训练方案需要标准化,吞咽困难评估的临床客观方法需要进一步验证。然而,术前吞咽训练有改善口腔癌患者生活质量的潜力。