Department of Surgery, Division of Pediatric General and Thoracic Surgery, University of Toronto Temerty Faculty of Medicine, Toronto, Canada
Ariadne Labs, Boston, Massachusetts, USA.
BMJ Paediatr Open. 2024 Oct 8;8(1):e002824. doi: 10.1136/bmjpo-2024-002824.
Enhanced recovery after surgery (ERAS) guidelines have been successfully applied to children and neonates. There is a need to provide evidence-based consensus recommendations to manage neonatal pain perioperatively to ensure adequate analgesia while minimising harmful side effects.
Following a stakeholder needs assessment, an international guideline development committee (GDC) was established. A modified Delphi consensus iteratively defined the scope of patient and procedure inclusion, topic selection and recommendation content regarding the pharmacologic management of neonatal pain. Critical appraisal tools assessed the relevance and quality of full-text studies. Each recommendation underwent a formal Grades of Recommendation, Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) assessment of the quality of evidence and expert consensus was used to determine the strength of recommendations.
The GDC included paediatric anaesthesiologists, surgeons, and ERAS methodology experts. The population was defined as neonates at >32 weeks gestational age within 30 days of life undergoing surgery or painful procedures associated with surgery. Topic selection targeted pharmacologic opioid-minimising strategies. A total of 4249 abstracts were screened for non-opioid analgesia and 738 abstracts for the use of locoregional analgesia. Full-text review of 18 and 9 articles, respectively, resulted in two final recommendations with a moderate quality of evidence to use regular acetaminophen and to consider the use of locoregional analgesia. There was inadequate evidence to guide the use of other non-opioid adjuncts in this population.
Evidence-based, ERAS-driven consensus recommendations were developed to minimise opioid usage in neonates. Further research is required in this population to optimize multimodal strategies for pain control.
手术加速康复(ERAS)指南已成功应用于儿童和新生儿。有必要提供循证共识建议来管理新生儿围手术期疼痛,以确保充分的镇痛效果,同时尽量减少有害的副作用。
在进行利益相关者需求评估后,成立了一个国际指南制定委员会(GDC)。通过改良 Delphi 共识,逐步确定了纳入患者和手术的范围、主题选择以及关于新生儿疼痛药物管理的推荐内容。使用关键评估工具评估了全文研究的相关性和质量。每个推荐建议都经过正式的推荐分级、评估、制定和评价(GRADE)评估,以评估证据质量,并使用专家共识来确定推荐建议的强度。
GDC 包括儿科麻醉师、外科医生和 ERAS 方法学专家。研究人群定义为胎龄>32 周、术后 30 天内接受手术或与手术相关的疼痛操作的新生儿。主题选择针对的是药物镇痛的最小化策略。共筛选了 4249 份非阿片类镇痛药和 738 份局部区域镇痛的摘要。对 18 篇和 9 篇文章的全文进行了审查,最终得出了两项具有中度证据质量的推荐建议,即常规使用对乙酰氨基酚和考虑使用局部区域镇痛。在该人群中,没有足够的证据来指导其他非阿片类辅助药物的使用。
制定了基于循证医学和 ERAS 的共识推荐建议,以减少新生儿阿片类药物的使用。需要在该人群中进一步开展研究,以优化疼痛控制的多模式策略。